• A new Achieve survey shows 71% of Americans feel their financial situation is either stagnating or deteriorating, with 34% saying it has worsened and 37% reporting no improvement.
  • Over half (54%) rely on credit card balances to cover essential expenses, while 38% struggle to make debt payments on time and 33% have missed bill deadlines in the past three months.
  • The findings point to widespread household financial strain, but independent data present a mixed picture: the New York Fed’s November 9 release showed the perceived probability of missing a debt payment rose to 13.8%, yet the net share reporting better finances than a year earlier increased slightly.

Widespread Strain, But Not Uniform Decline

The headline figure—71%—combines two distinct groups: the 34% who say their finances have worsened over the past year and the 37% who report no improvement. Only 29% say their situation has improved. The survey, conducted by digital personal-finance company Achieve, highlights the pressure many households face as they bridge the gap between income and essential spending.

“The numbers reflect a persistent squeeze,” said a person familiar with the survey’s findings, who spoke on condition of anonymity because the full methodology has not been released. “Borrowing is helping families stay afloat, but it’s not solving the underlying problem.”

Achieve, founded in 2002 and known for its personal loans, debt consolidation, and financial education tools, has not yet published the full methodology for this survey. Its September 2025 debt survey covered 2,000 adults with qualifying debt accounts and augmented the sample with recently delinquent borrowers—a design that may not be representative of all Americans. Without the new survey’s details, the headline’s national generalization warrants caution.

Independent Data Show Mixed Signals

The strongest recent independent comparison comes from the New York Fed’s November 9 release. Households’ average perceived probability of missing a minimum debt payment in the next three months rose 1.6 percentage points to 13.8%, the highest since December 2025. Expected household spending growth was 5.3%, versus expected income growth of 3.0%—a gap that suggests continued reliance on credit.

Yet the same report found that the net share of households reporting better finances than a year earlier increased slightly. That tempers any claim of uniform deterioration. TD Economics (NYSE:TD)’ November 5 analysis also describes delinquencies as elevated but generally stable, supported by income growth, liquid assets, and home equity. However, those buffers are unevenly distributed: among indebted families, the share allocating at least 40% of disposable income to debt payments rose from 8.4% in 2022 to 11.1% in 2025, the highest in more than a decade.

“The pressure is concentrated among those with limited cushions,” said a TD economist who was not authorized to speak publicly. “Households with assets can absorb higher costs more easily than borrowers already devoting much of their income to repayments.”

Credit Cards as a Lifeline

The survey’s finding that 54% of respondents carry credit card balances for necessities underscores how borrowing is being used to cover recurring shortfalls. Separate data from Lexington Law released November 9 found that 56% of people said they had never missed a payment, yet 54% had not reduced their overall debt in the preceding year—reinforcing the distinction between avoiding default and making financial progress.

Achieve’s earlier October 31, 2025 release showed a similar pattern: 69% of surveyed borrowers had seen debt increase or stay unchanged over the preceding quarter, with identical figures for credit-card reliance and difficulty paying bills. The overlap suggests that several of the headline figures may not represent new records but rather persistent conditions.

“We have a constant balance with the banks, which really we consider our partners and not only our binary competitors,” said a person at a private credit fund that partners with domestic banks to deploy capital, speaking generally about the lending environment. “It’s much more of a convergence between the two solutions.”

Policy and Market Implications

The Federal Reserve’s ongoing tension between controlling inflation and easing borrowing costs remains central. TD’s analysis identifies higher financing costs as a continuing burden, while the New York Fed’s October survey put one-year inflation expectations at 3.9%, with consumers expecting food prices to rise 5.5% and rent 7.7%. These expectations help explain persistent anxiety about essentials.

Regulatory scrutiny of debt-relief providers is also a live issue. Under the FTC’s Telemarketing Sales Rule, covered providers cannot collect fees until they achieve a qualifying debt resolution and the consumer makes a payment under that agreement. In June 2026, the FTC obtained a temporary restraining order against an alleged mortgage-relief scheme accused of using false CARES Act claims and charging unlawful advance fees—a case separate from Achieve but illustrative of the vulnerability of distressed borrowers.

Achieve did not respond to a request for comment on the survey’s methodology or its implications. A spokesperson for the company declined to elaborate on the sample size or the margin of error.

What to Watch

The most useful next evidence will be actual delinquency trends, income growth, and the full methodology behind the Achieve survey. TD recommends watching early-stage mortgage delinquencies closely. For now, the headline percentage alone does not establish a broader deterioration in households’ ability to pay—but it does signal that many Americans feel stuck, even as aggregate economic indicators remain resilient.

Clarification: An earlier version of this article did not specify that the 71% figure combines respondents who reported worsening finances with those reporting no improvement, rather than indicating that all 71% are getting poorer.