- Senate Intelligence Committee Chairman Tom Cotton says Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick repeatedly ignored warnings about potential AI chip smuggling to China, and that Commerce approved exports of more than 800,000 Nvidia (NASDAQ:NVDA) and AMD (NASDAQ:AMD) chips to China through May 11.
- Cotton expects Congress to pursue stricter semiconductor export controls, potentially including chip-tracking requirements and restrictions on advanced manufacturing equipment.
- The accusation escalates an interagency dispute over export-control enforcement, with Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent also criticising Commerce; Nvidia's strong financial results and new board committee on national security underscore the high stakes.
Senator Tom Cotton has accused Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and senior department officials of ignoring warnings that Nvidia chips were being diverted to China through Singapore-based Megaspeed, according to a Wall Street Journal (NASDAQ:NWSA) report. The allegation, which Cotton's office declined to elaborate on, adds congressional weight to an escalating dispute over whether the Commerce Department failed to act decisively on export-control concerns.
Cotton Details Chip Exports and Legislative Plans
Senate Intelligence Committee Chairman Tom Cotton said Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick repeatedly ignored warnings about potential AI chip smuggling to China. Cotton specifically cited concerns about Megaspeed, a company linked to the ongoing Nvidia investigation. According to the report, Commerce approved exports of more than 800,000 Nvidia and AMD chips to China through May 11. Nvidia maintains its shipments were legally authorized.
Cotton expects Congress to pursue stricter semiconductor export controls, potentially including chip-tracking requirements and restrictions on advanced manufacturing equipment. The allegations intensify scrutiny of U.S. technology exports and the Commerce Department's oversight.
The charge comes amid a broader interagency conflict. On November 14, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent publicly said Treasury supported restrictions on Megaspeed but Commerce failed to impose them, the Journal reported. The administration's internal disagreement over timing and authority has intensified pressure on Commerce to explain its handling of the case.
The government has pushed back. In a joint statement on November 17, Commerce and Justice said Commerce opened the Megaspeed investigation in 2024, requested Nvidia sales records in May 2025, and conducted an on-site inspection with Singaporean authorities in June 2025. Nvidia placed Megaspeed on its own "no sell" list that June, and Justice subsequently took the lead in the criminal investigation. The statement did not address Cotton's specific claims.
Nvidia's Strong Results Amid Controversy
The controversy has not dented Nvidia's financial performance. For its fiscal third quarter ended October 25, 2026, Nvidia reported revenue of $115.8 billion, up 103% year over year, and net income of $65.3 billion, more than double the prior year. Data-center revenue reached $107.6 billion, up 110%. The company guided next-quarter revenue to $130 billion, plus or minus 3%, assuming no China data-center compute revenue. That outlook exceeds the $125.25 billion analyst consensus cited by Reuters (NASDAQ:TRI).
On November 17, Nvidia also announced the creation of a board committee on national security and export controls, a governance change that highlights the growing regulatory scrutiny. The move came as the company continues its search for a permanent CEO following Jensen Huang's resignation on November 12. Finance chief Colette Kress is serving as interim CEO, and Chairman Harvey Jones said the board would not rehire Huang.
Megaspeed at the Center
Megaspeed, a Singapore-based Nvidia customer, purchased billions of dollars of chips, according to reporting. The government identifies Alice Huang as its CEO at the time of the June 2025 inspection. The reviewed sources do not provide reliable current financial figures for the company. The case remains under investigation, and no final finding of criminal wrongdoing has been established.
Cotton, a vocal China hawk, has also urged Commerce to add Chinese memory maker ChangXin Memory Technologies to the Entity List. That separate issue illustrates the widening semiconductor-security agenda.
Political and Market Implications
The dispute has drawn attention from lawmakers on both sides. Democratic senators Elizabeth Warren and Chris Coons have sought preservation of administration records, while Republican criticism includes Cotton's demands and calls for Lutnick to explain his decisions publicly. President Trump has defended Lutnick, according to the Journal.
Investors appear focused on Nvidia's operating strength. Shares rose 4% in extended trading after the November 17 results, though Reuters noted the stock remained roughly $2 trillion below an early-October high. The broader decline cannot be attributed solely to the Megaspeed headline, but the controversy adds a layer of regulatory and legal risk.
As the Justice Department-led investigation proceeds, the key question is whether Commerce should have imposed restrictions sooner. The government's confirmation of investigative work does not settle Cotton's criticism, and the absence of blacklisting does not prove no enforcement occurred. With congressional document requests likely to follow, the case will test the independence and effectiveness of U.S. export controls.