- US crude futures fell $2 as recovering oil flows through the Strait of Hormuz reinforced expectations of surplus supply.
- The IEA now forecasts a fourth-quarter supply surplus of 1.7 million barrels per day, reversing its previous deficit forecast.
- Despite the drop, security risks persist, with reports of tanker incidents providing underlying support to prices.
US crude oil futures fell $2 on Thursday as signs of recovering oil flows through the Strait of Hormuz reinforced expectations of a supply surplus, shifting the market's focus from wartime shortages to oversupply concerns.
The price move came as the International Energy Agency's latest assessment, reported on November 16, forecast fourth-quarter global oil supply averaging 105 million barrels per day—1.7 million bpd above expected demand. That reverses the IEA's previous forecast of a fourth-quarter deficit. The surplus projection, combined with weaker demand signals from China, has pressured crude prices.
China's October refinery throughput fell 2% month over month and 8.1% year over year, reinforcing the bearish demand picture. Reuters (NASDAQ:TRI) calculated that higher production and imports, alongside reduced refining, implied Chinese crude inventories increased by approximately 492,000 barrels per day during October.
While the headline move was a $2 drop, the latest verified price snapshot in Reuters reports—at 07:57 GMT on November 16—showed US West Texas Intermediate (WTI) at $88.65 a barrel, up 9 cents, and Brent at $95.89, up 5 cents. Earlier that morning, WTI had traded at $88.34 and Brent at $95.30. The reversal illustrates competing forces: improving supply is weighing on prices, while shipping-security risks still provide support.
Fragile Recovery
The recovery in Gulf exports is more complete than traffic through the Strait of Hormuz itself. Reuters commentary, citing Kpler, put October crude shipments through the strait at 10.3 million bpd versus 13.5 million bpd before the war, excluding Iranian shipments. Including alternative routes through Saudi Arabia's Yanbu and the UAE's Fujairah, regional crude exports reached 16.6 million bpd, close to their pre-war 17 million bpd, though those figures use different coverage from broader oil-supply estimates.
The recovery is increasing competition among suppliers. Saudi Arabia cut its December Arab Light price for Asian customers by $2 a barrel, while producers in the US, Brazil and Canada have also increased output in response to the earlier shortage, according to Reuters analysis. However, refinery damage, expensive shipping and security-related logistics remain bottlenecks, meaning surplus crude can coexist with tight diesel or gasoline markets.
Political risks remain elevated. US–Iran relations are the principal market risk, with the conflict in its ninth month and no durable settlement secured. Reuters reported Iranian claims of new tanker mine incidents on November 16 but explicitly said it could not independently verify them. Naval protection and alternative routes have enabled recovery without full normalization.
Emergency stocks remain part of the policy response. The IEA said 71 million barrels from the emergency release pledged in March remained scheduled for availability by the end of February, including 15 million barrels of diesel. Additionally, Washington extended a Jones Act waiver for another 90 days, allowing foreign tankers to move fuel between US ports, which can ease distribution constraints.
The price drop comes as traders and analysts debate whether surplus supply now outweighs war risk. KCM Trade analyst Tim Waterer described traders as considering excess supply rather than persistent tightness for the first time since the conflict began. Nevertheless, the November 16 price rebound shows how quickly tanker incidents can revive the geopolitical risk premium.
Analysts are not unanimous about the size of the surplus. JPMorgan (NYSE:JPM) estimates surpluses of 1.1 million bpd in September and 1.4 million bpd in October, while Goldman Sachs (NYSE:GS) assessed those months as broadly balanced. BMI's base case is a preliminary agreement to reopen Hormuz in the first quarter of 2027, followed by improving maritime security and more normal freight and insurance markets—a scenario, not an agreed timetable.
In the short term, the IEA's surplus forecast supports continued pressure on crude prices if export recovery persists. However, security shocks could interrupt the downtrend, as evidenced by the intraday rebound on November 16. The market remains caught between recovering supply and lingering geopolitical risks.