- Housing starts jumped 9.9% to a 1.309 million annual pace, beating forecasts, but building permits fell 7.4% to 1.295 million, missing expectations.
- Single-family starts rose 4.0% while multifamily surged 23.6%, yet single-family permits dropped 8.7%, signaling potential weakness ahead.
- Builder confidence fell to its lowest since 2012, with many cutting prices and offering incentives amid elevated mortgage rates.
A Rebound That May Not Last
U.S. housing starts rebounded sharply in October, rising 9.9% to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 1.309 million, according to the latest government data. The increase reversed a 7.0% decline in September and easily topped the 1.245 million consensus estimate. However, building permits, a leading indicator of future construction, fell 7.4% to 1.295 million, well below the 1.377 million forecast. Single-family permits dropped 8.7%, suggesting the rebound may be short-lived as borrowing costs remain elevated.
The divergence between starts and permits highlights the uneven nature of the housing market. Starts measure homes that have broken ground, while permits reflect authorizations for future projects. Builders can start projects approved in earlier months, but a sustained drop in permits points to fewer projects ahead. The October surge was driven largely by a 23.6% jump in multifamily construction to a 445,000 annual pace, while single-family starts rose 4.0% to 864,000. The volatile multifamily segment can skew monthly figures.
Builder Confidence Sinks
The housing market faces mounting headwinds. The NAHB/Wells Fargo (NYSE:WFC) builder-confidence index fell four points to 25, its lowest since April 2012, according to data released Tuesday. In the survey, 46% of builders reported cutting prices by an average of 6%, and 68% offered sales incentives. Mortgage rates above 7%, high material and energy costs, and labor shortages continue to weigh on the market, the NAHB said.
"Builders are doing what they can to move inventory, but affordability remains a major challenge," said one industry analyst, who requested anonymity to speak candidly. "The drop in permits shows that builders are pulling back on new projects until they see a clearer path for demand."
Completions, which matter more for buyers and renters, were already 14.0% below year-ago levels in September. A start does not add a move-in-ready home, and a sustained decline in permits could further constrain supply and worsen affordability in already tight markets.
Looking Ahead
The next check on the housing market comes on November 25, when the Census Bureau releases revised October permits and new-home sales data. Economists will watch for any revisions to September's starts figure, which was initially reported as a 5.2% decline but later revised to a 7.0% drop. The single-family versus multifamily breakdown will also be key, as a rebound driven mainly by apartments would say little about a recovery in detached-home construction.
For now, the October data offers a mixed picture: a temporary surge in groundbreaking, but warning signs for future construction. With mortgage rates expected to stay high, the housing market's path to recovery remains uncertain.