- USTR Jamieson Greer said the US is receiving some needed rare earths but wants more progress, noting compliance is not perfect.
- China reportedly extended its suspension of October 2025 export controls until January 2027, but older April 2025 licensing requirements remain active.
- Manufacturers face uneven access to critical minerals, with some materials like yttrium nearly unobtainable, even as shipments continue.
Greer: 'Getting Some Rare Earths That We Need'
US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer said the United States is receiving some of the rare earths it needs but that compliance with a trade arrangement is not perfect, signaling continued friction in a critical supply chain.
"We're getting some rare earths that we need," Greer said in an interview with CNBC on Wednesday. "We would like to see more progress. Compliance is not perfect."
His comments come after a November 6 videoconference between Greer, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, and Chinese Vice Premier He Lifeng. The US readout called for "concrete actions" to fulfill China's commitments on agricultural purchases and rare earths, without specifying shortfalls.
Uneven Implementation
Rare earths are vital for electric-vehicle motors, electronics, and defense systems. China's dominance in mining and refining makes any licensing delay consequential for global manufacturers. While some shipments are moving, companies report lengthy, opaque licensing procedures. A July survey by the US-China Business Council described some rare earths as "nearly unobtainable."
The core issue is that China's April 2025 licensing requirements for seven rare-earth elements—including dysprosium, terbium, and yttrium—remain in place. A reported extension of the suspension of China's broader October 2025 export controls, now said to run through January 10, 2027, does not remove those older licensing rules. Consequently, manufacturers may still struggle to obtain material promptly.
"The extension buys negotiating time ahead of an expected Trump-Xi meeting at APEC in Shenzhen later this month," said a person familiar with the matter. "But it doesn't resolve the licensing bottleneck."
Industry Impact and Outlook
US manufacturers have reported difficulties securing sufficient supplies, and the issue extends beyond America's borders: Japanese manufacturers also face shortages, with yttrium particularly constrained. Lynas Rare Earths (ASX:LYC) is not expected to begin yttrium production at its Malaysian facility until 2028, highlighting the gap between diversification announcements and commercially usable supply.
The broader dispute, linked to the October 2025 Busan trade arrangement, ties critical minerals to agricultural purchases and tariff measures. Washington demands actual deliveries, while Beijing has raised "serious concern" about recent US trade restrictions. Both sides continue direct consultations.
The most likely near-term outcome is continued negotiation alongside uneven supplies. Key indicators will be actual shipment volumes, licensing turnaround times, and any concrete commitments from the leaders' meeting—not just another announcement that talks were constructive.
A USTR spokesperson did not respond to a request for comment on specific shipment data. The Chinese embassy in Washington also did not immediately respond.