Aug 2, 2024
Operator
Good morning. I'm Ashley Curtis, Assistant Vice President of Investor Relations, and I would like to welcome you to Tanger Inc's Second Quarter 2024 Conference Call.
Yesterday evening, we issued our earnings release as well as our supplemental information package and investor presentation. This information is available on our IR website, investors.tanger.com.
Please note this call may contain forward-looking statements that are subject to numerous risks and uncertainties, and actual results could differ materially from those projected. We direct you to our filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission for a detailed discussion of these risks and uncertainties.
During the call, we will also discuss non-GAAP financial measures as defined by SEC Regulation G. Reconciliations of these non-GAAP measures to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures are included in our earnings release and in our supplemental information.
This call is being recorded for rebroadcast for a period of time in the future. As such, it is important to note that management's comments include time-sensitive information that may only be accurate as of today's date, August 2, 2024.
At this time, all participants are in listen-only mode. Following management's prepared comments, the call will be open for your questions.
We request that everyone ask only one question and one follow-up question, and if time permits, we are happy for you to reach you for additional questions. On the call today will be Stephen Yalof, President and Chief Executive Officer; and Michael Bilerman, Chief Financial Officer and Chief Investment Officer.
In addition, other members of our leadership team will be available for Q&A. I will now turn the call over to Stephen Yalof.
Please go ahead.
Stephen Yalof
I'm pleased to announce another quarter of strong performance and an increase in our full-year guidance. Our same center NOI grew by 8% from the prior year while FFO per share was up 13%.
These results demonstrate the continued execution of our strategy and our focus on optimizing our value proposition for both retailers and shoppers. We are elevating the retail mix in our centers and creating a community experience to drive traffic and increase engagement.
Our centers are well located in fast-growing markets that benefit from an attractive mix of tourists, seasonal and local residents. We are delivering a personalized and engaging experience to target each of these audiences.
Year-to-date traffic was held to last year's levels with growth in May and June. We've also seen continued positive momentum in sales with another sequential quarterly increase in our sales productivity for the trailing 12 months.
We continue to enhance the value of our centers for our customers by curating the right mix of brands, food and beverage and entertainment uses and elevating and creating an exciting and dynamic shopping experience. This strategy has led us to achieve our 10th consecutive quarter of positive rent spreads, which drives total rent and NOI growth.
Demand for our space continues to be strong, driving robust leasing activity. We've executed 2 million square feet of leases over the trailing 12 months at an average spread of 15%, which we believe demonstrates the importance our retailers' place on being in a Tanger center.
We ended the quarter with 96.5% occupancy. As of quarter-end, we had renewals executed or in process for 66% of the space expiring this year ahead of last year's pace.
We continue to believe in our real estate and focus on optimizing our merchandising mix whether through renewals or re-tenanting where appropriate. We are very pleased with the execution of our strategy to enhance and diversify our retailer mix with more productive brands.
In addition to growing relationships with our existing tenants, we've seen approximately half of our re-tenanting activity come from new to portfolio brands over the past year and a half. And many are seeing success and expanding.
For example, we've executed leases for six new Sephora stores, five of which are under construction and will open in the coming months. We're also activating peripheral land with concepts that draw additional traffic.
Our new tenant pipeline is strong and we are encouraged by the momentum going into next year as we grow relationships with new and innovative brands. As publicly announced, Rue21 and Express, both recently went through bankruptcy proceedings.
We maintain proactive relationships with all of our tenants and we are prepared for these situations and work expeditiously to a resolution. Out of the 50 combined stores in our portfolio, only one was rejected, and we elected to recapture three other locations with near-term expirations to immediately re-tenant at greater rents.
The Rue21 stores closed while they went through their ownership change and they have begun to reopen and will all be open prior to the holiday selling season. In May, we published our 2023 ESG report, which discusses our focus on enhancing our sustainability metrics, resource efficiency, stakeholder engagement, and return on these investments.
A few highlights include our notable increase in renewable energy production and the further rollout of electric vehicle charging stations, our initiatives to foster a healthy workplace culture and community involvement and our commitment to diversity, governance and investor engagement. In June, we were honored to receive the 2024 Nareit Investor CARE Gold Award for communication and reporting excellence.
I want to thank the entire Tanger team, our customers and all of our stakeholders for their continued support. I'd now like to turn the call over to Michael to discuss our financial results, balance sheet, and outlook for the remainder of the year.
Michael Bilerman
Thank you, Steve. Today I'm going to discuss our second quarter financial results, our balance sheet activity, and our increased guidance for the year.
In the second quarter, we delivered Core FFO of $0.53 a share compared to $0.47 a share in the second quarter of the prior year as we saw continued core growth along with the contributions from the three new centers that we added in the fourth quarter of last year. Same center NOI increased 8% for the quarter, driven by higher rental revenues from the continued strong retailer demand and robust leasing activity, leading to increased base rents as well as higher expense recoveries.
Our second quarter same center NOI also benefited from flat operating expenses versus last year, in part based on the timing of our operating expenses throughout the year. Within our non-same center pool, we are pleased with the performance at our three recently added centers in Nashville, Huntsville and Asheville.
They are performing in line with our expectations and we are continuing to execute on our leasing, merchandising and marketing strategies at each center. Our balance sheet remains well positioned to support our internal and external growth initiatives with low leverage, a largely fixed-rate balance sheet, almost full availability on our lines of credit, essentially no debt maturities until late 2026, and ample free cash flow after dividends given our low dividend payout ratio.
At quarter end, we had $1.6 billion of pro rata and net debt with a weighted average interest rate of 4.1%. Our net debt to adjusted EBITDAre was 5.4 times for the 12 months ended June 30 and pro forma for a full year of adjusted EBITDA for the three new centers that we added in the fourth quarter, we estimate that our leverage ratio would be between 5.1 times to 5.2 times, still one of the lowest in the retail and REIT sectors.
As previously announced, during the quarter, we also extended the maturity, increased the borrowing capacity and reduced our pricing on our unsecured lines of credit. At quarter-end, we had $585 million of availability under our lines and $20 million of cash and cash equivalents.
In April, our Board approved a 5.8% increase in our dividend to $1.10 per share annualized, with the shares yielding approximately 4% today. Our quarterly cash dividend remains well covered with a continued low payout ratio providing free cash flow to support our growth.
Now, turning to our increased guidance for 2024. We are increasing our core FFO per share expectations to a range of $2.05 to $2.12 from a prior range of $2.03 to $2.11, implying 5% to 8% core FFO growth.
We are increasing our same center NOI growth expectations by 75 basis points at the midpoint to a range of 3.25% to 4.75%, up from 2.25% to 4.25% last quarter. The increases are due to the better than expected performance in the second quarter and our outlook for the balance of the year.
For additional details on our key assumptions, please see our release issued last night. And now, I'd like to turn the call for questions.
Operator?
Operator
[Operator Instructions] Our first question is from Jeff Spector with Bank of America. Please proceed.
Andrew Reale
Good morning. It's Andrew Reale on for Jeff.
Thanks for taking our questions. Could you just discuss in a little more detail the property expense timing benefit in the period?
I guess, what specifically saw the benefit? And are there any timing impacts to be aware of in the second half?
Stephen Yalof
Thanks, Andrew. Yeah, when you look at our operating expenses between what we spend on our common area of maintenance as well as our marketing expenses, those could be variable through the year, but in part, it impacts what was spent in the year prior in terms of that year-over-year comparison.
So when we look at our operating expenses in the second quarter, they were flat year-over-year. And as we think about the full year, that sort of blends into our expectations of same center NOI, which we raised at both the low and the high-end.
We just have some variable timing as that expense flows through each quarter, affecting that year-over-year on a quarterly basis impact.
Andrew Reale
Okay. Thank you.
And then guidance suggests some meaningful deceleration in the same center NOI growth in the back half. Is that just largely due to more downtime as you ramp up re-tenanting efforts, or are there other factors to call out there?
Thank you.
Stephen Yalof
We look at our business on an annual basis. And when you look at where our guidance is moving, what you've seen is both that low-end coming up and the high end moving up.
And so, on a quarterly basis, just going back to that first question, that quarterly impact from the same center perspective is going to get impacted by the timing of that expenses year-over-year. But in aggregate, for the year, our business is producing very well, as we've continued to see that growth.
I would say on the revenue side, there is a little bit of downtime associated as those Rue stores reopen, but that's not a significant impact. And all of that has an exit rate as we go into next year as all those stores will be open.
Operator
Our next question is from Floris van Dijkum with Compass Point. Please proceed.
Floris van Dijkum
Hey, morning. Question on the Rue21 leases, I think you had 20 before, 18 are continuing.
Maybe if you could talk about the economics of those leases relative to where they were before. And will all 18 open before the -- I think you said before the holiday season, are going to -- some of them are going to open in the third quarter as well?
Stephen Yalof
Good morning, Floris, and thanks for the question. So with regard to Rue21, yeah, we started with 20.
We'll have 18 stores reopened before the end of the year, many of which are already reopened. As far as the deals themselves, we don't really get into the details of each of these deals, but just -- we called out in our prepared remarks the two of those stores we elected to take back because we were able to replace that tenancy almost immediately with higher paying rent tenants mitigating part of that expense as well.
Remember, post-COVID, we made some interesting deals with some tenants that were in bankruptcy, a lot of which we lean far more heavily into the over-rent piece of the equation. We think that Rue21 with the new leadership will really pay us back.
Our shoppers in our centers really love that brand. And under this new leadership, we're looking forward to great results coming out of those stores.
I will say the first one that reopened in our portfolio under the new leadership was in our Mebane North Carolina Center right down the street from our corporate office here. And I was customer number one.
It was a great shopping experience. The stores look amazing.
Floris van Dijkum
Thanks, Steve. Maybe if I could follow up, and have you guys comment on the transaction markets and what you're seeing and what we can expect.
And is it more likely that we're going to see another lifestyle center potentially being added to the -- or is it -- is there enough opportunity in the outlet sector as well, where you could add another outlet before the end of the year?
Stephen Yalof
Thanks, Floris. By practice, we only get to announce deals when they're executed.
I think we are very active in the marketplace looking across each of the strategies that we're after and deals will come about. It is a competitive marketplace.
The lens that we are looking through is where can we add value in deals that we want to bring into the Tanger portfolio, where we can create that value from our leasing, our marketing, and our operations to really drive value over time for our stakeholders. And the balance sheet is extraordinarily well positioned with low leverage and a lot of liquidity to be able to act.
Opportunistically when deals come about, we're going to remain very prudent and disciplined on our external growth. And we have a lot of internal opportunities as we continue to grow our same center NOI and activate a lot of our peripheral land.
Operator
Our next question is from Todd Thomas with KeyBanc Capital Markets. Please proceed.
Todd Thomas
Hi, thanks. Good morning.
I wanted to follow up on the same store and timing of expenses just to help understand the quarterly cadence in the second half. I think you spoke previously about the full-year expense recovery rate being in the mid-80% range, may be slightly better, which would suggest a very steep decline or drag from net recoveries in the second half of the year.
Does the updated guidance and same store forecast include an update to the recovery rate for the full year that you're anticipating? Or is that sort of middle mid to maybe high-80% range still the right place to be for the full year?
Stephen Yalof
Yeah. Thanks, Todd.
And I think you hit it right, which is our expense recovery rate because our TAM is largely fixed and because we have variable expenses, and those expenses tend to be heavier from variable expenses in the back half than they are in the first half, just naturally, the percentage is going to be lower in the second half, right? And so we continue to believe, you saw the expense recovery rate in the first half averaged about 90%.
And we continue to expect to be in the mid-80s for the full year, which would imply sort of high-70s, low-80s in the back half from a recovery rate as TAM is largely fixed and that expense load will be a little bit variable in the second half.
Todd Thomas
Okay. And then in terms of thinking about 2025 a little bit relative to this year, how should we think about, I guess, net recoveries going forward?
I know that there's, the leasing -- some of the leasing initiatives, and you've talked about the structure of the leases and so forth that are underway and how you've been transitioning the tenant base a little bit. Can you sustain this high expense recovery rate going forward?
Is there a little bit of room to the upside still? Or could it potentially be a drag next year as we think about the year-over-year comps?
Stephen Yalof
So we're not prepared to give 2025 guidance, but stay tuned for that for next February. But our strategy is we continue to push rent.
You see the leasing spreads that we disclose in the supplemental that pushes both base rent and expense recoveries. So we're trying to grow that amount and we're trying to operate as efficiently as possible in terms of our expenses.
And so these trends, I mean, that's what we're trying to keep on driving NOI growth. That's the whole name of the game is trying to drive NOI and cash flow growth.
And so, that's what we'll continue to try to push each and every day.
Operator
Our next question is from Craig Mailman with Citigroup. Please proceed.
Craig Mailman
Hey, good morning. Steve, I was curious, adding Sephora to the portfolio was a good win.
I'm just wondering, have you had a pickup in calls or interest from tenants you've been courting or just new tenants you haven't really spoken with post that announcement, who are interested in, maybe opening a first outlet -- outpost or interested in Tanger now more so, given that announcement?
Stephen Yalof
Yeah. The answer is yes.
We said in our prepared remarks earlier that half of our new leasing in the past 18 months has been new to Tanger platform retailers. I think they're responding to a number of things.
First of all, just the change in the makeup of our shopping center, where we're pivoting from pure play outlet retail in most of our properties to adding better food and beverage, adding entertainment, adding local uses and better amenities. We think it speaks to the local customer as well as the tourists that shopping in the marketplace, extends stays, it gets more customers in the door and increases frequency.
That's the Sephora -- the Sephora deals will do just that. I mean, the Sephora's got a very loyal shopper that will shop our shopping centers far more frequently than they may for a traditional outlet brand.
And we think the synergy of those two together will definitely open the door for further conversations with brands that are looking to the outlet platform to get in front of a customer they may not see in any of their other channels.
Craig Mailman
And just separately, you guys consistently have kind of put up good rent spreads here. What is the update on where kind of the blended OCR is versus that target, 10% to 12%?
How much -- how many of your centers also are kind of already at that target versus centers that you have more work to do? Just give us a sense of the breakdown of that as well because sometimes it gets lost on the average.
Stephen Yalof
Sure. It makes sense.
And look, I would say, we disposed of a few non-core assets over the past two or three years. Most of the remaining centers in our portfolio are all positive contributors.
So currently, we're at about a 9.4% OCR. We only started talking about this several years ago.
We were at an 8%, and said that we've got opportunity to get into the double digits. It takes time to get there because we certainly don't touch every single lease every year, but the spreads are great contributors to us growing our rents.
We have a strategy of replacing versus renewing. Our retention rates have been historically 95% over the past few years.
We're leaning a little bit more heavily into replacing some of the retailers that need to either be right-sized or just aren't as productive as they might have been with far more productive retailers, evidenced by the Sephora brand that you just mentioned and a number of others. So we think all of those will lead to us to continue to drive rents, grow our productivity in each of our centers on a sales-per-square-foot basis, and make our shopping centers far more interesting for the customers that come and visit us every day.
Operator
Our next question is from Greg McGinniss with Scotiabank. Please proceed.
Greg McGinniss
Hey, good morning. I just want to follow up on your comment regarding activating peripheral land.
Can you give us any details in terms of how much space is left to add outparcels or just kind of entitlements on square footage? Any sort of detail you can provide in terms of what the opportunity set is on that peripheral land would be appreciated.
Stephen Yalof
Sure. Well, first of all, we've said in the past, and I'll reiterate that over half of our shopping centers have some peripheral lands attached to them.
Most of that land is already approved by virtue of being on a retail footprint already. So the improvements are there, the parking facilities are there.
So that peripheral land activation is a great source of revenue for us because it requires relatively low capital and relatively high returns. There are some instances where we all have a pad or two, and other instances where we have acres of land that were earmarked for either a Phase 2 of one of our productive shopping centers or some alternative uses, some of which that we've executed to in recent years are hotel pads, entertainment uses like Dave & Buster's, sit-down restaurants, from Cracker Barrel to Texas Roadhouse, and most recently, our most recent executed lease in Savannah, Georgia, where we've added a Planet Fitness.
So we're looking to monetize that land, but also create important destinations for the local catchment as well as the tourists that shop in our shopping centers.
Greg McGinniss
Okay. I do think that we investors may appreciate a little more disclosure in terms of where money is being spent on that peripheral land, expected yields on that, how much is available.
But, as my follow-up question, just looking at the Huntsville occupancy…
Stephen Yalof
Greg?
Greg McGinniss
Yeah.
Stephen Yalof
Page 10 of our supplemental includes all the money that we spend for all of our activities, both what we invest in the portfolio, new developments, and all the TAs, and second -- and our operating CapEx, so the dollars are all there.
Greg McGinniss
Yeah, no, I appreciate that. Just some details on the projects would be appreciated.
Just for the follow-up on the Huntsville occupancy, it seems like there's been a couple of declines over the last few quarters. I'm just curious what's driving that?
How touring's going for that property? What you expect that kind of on the long-term lease up and over the next few years, what kind of tenants you're trying to add in?
And what might be happening on the occupancy front?
Stephen Yalof
Sure. Well, we closed the deal with an occupied Bed Bath & Beyond that we knew was going to close.
We had a number of retailers interested in that box. We're under contract with one right now.
Initially, our strategy was re-tenanting where that location was, but we're moving forward with a deal that's currently in process, and that'll get the occupancy number up because that's really what that material decline or the decline that you're talking about was really due to that one space, pretty big space relative to the size of shopping center. But with regard to leasing, we've added Warby Parker.
We just executed a lease with Starbucks, and there's a number of new brands to come. That shopping center was a great buy for us at the going-in yield, but there's a lot of opportunity as spaces will start to turn over the next couple of years to re-tenant it and upgrade the retailer mix.
There's a lot of interest in the property. And as is our practice, we don't typically mention retailers until we've executed those leases.
So there'll be some really good news stories coming out of Huntsville, Alabama in the next coming months and quarters.
Operator
Our next question is from Samir Khanal with Evercore ISI. Please proceed.
Samir Khanal
Hey, good morning. Hey, Steve, can you comment on -- maybe a little bit more on sales and traffic?
I know you talked a little bit about in your commentary, but what have you seen in July? Sort of on -- for sales, maybe even traffic on a sequential basis, given you hear about the consumer being pressured with inflation, macro slowing.
Just trying to get a bit more color here. Thanks.
Stephen Yalof
Yeah. Well, we reported that our sales have grown sequentially the last two consecutive quarters against relatively flat traffic numbers, anticipating July, probably to follow the similar trend.
The good news part of that story is with very little new retail development, we still have a very active queue of retailers that are lining up to take space in our shopping centers. Now, there's been a lot of activity in the outlet business, all of which we think is really good for our industry.
L Catterton's investment in a European outlet company, the high occupancy at which Nashville opened, Tulsa, which is the premium center that will open in the coming weeks, we understand will open at a very high occupancy, really speaks to retailer interest in our space and the demand that's pushing the rents.
Samir Khanal
Okay. Thank you for that.
And then I guess, Michael, just in terms of capital allocation, I know, you spoke a little bit about sort of the potential opportunities out there in the open air side, maybe. But are you seeing more opportunities come to market at this point, given what interest rates have done over the last, let's call it, 90 days?
Michael Bilerman
Yeah, I think that there's definitely from a retail fundamental perspective, which is really across all the different formats. There certainly is interest and combined with the overall rate environment, I think that could unlock some opportunities.
And we'll just be prudent and disciplined as we go about them, and expect more stuff done, hopefully, will be on the market, and we have a big pool to fish in.
Operator
Our next question is from Caitlin Burrows with Goldman Sachs. Please proceed.
Caitlin Burrows
Hi, good morning. Maybe just some follow-ups on topics that we've broadly touched on, but given the focus on replacing or downsizing some underperforming tenants, I was surprised to see the leasing activity page showed the number of re-tenanted leases was -- seemed pretty similar to a year ago, although the square footage was up, maybe parts that were just halfway through the year.
But can you talk about what that year-to-date retention has been and actually how does the downside fit into that? But then also, the timeline of when you started taking a tougher stance on renewals, then you start signing those leases and the ultimate opening like have we started to see that yet or not quite?
Stephen Yalof
Well, we talked about our retention rates in '22 and -- our '21-'22 going into '23, probably being around the 95% level. I mean, most retailers don't want to close the store that's cash flowing positively that they've already made that investment in the store.
And if they have to take that positive cash flow and replace it someplace else, it's going to require capital in order to do so. Because of that, we've been very satisfied with a high retention rate because we're able to push our rents 10%, 12% from a lot of those retailers to stay.
On the flip side, on a re-tenanting basis where our spreads are significantly higher, we as a team here who's playing the long game has understood that from supply and demand point of view, there's not a tremendous amount of space and outlet centers available for leasing, that there's a number of tenants that are demanding space in our shopping centers. And because of that, we have an opportunity in time right now to really add exciting new tenants and brand storage centers but do so at rents considerably higher than the retailers that they're replacing.
With that said, we have a strategy now in mind of pushing new brands or requiring that existing brands, who aren't as productive as they might have been in the past, either invest in their stores, downsize because we believe a lot of brands that might be oversized in our portfolio that are still very viable by downsizing their brand or their store footprint can be as productive, if not more so, in a much smaller footprint. So with our retention, our resizing, our replacing with necessary strategy, we're only going to increase the number of store opportunities for the customer to shop when they visit us, increase the variety of stores in our footprint, push rents and grow productivity on an organic basis.
And we think there's a lot of room for growth there.
Caitlin Burrows
Got it. And obviously, the ability to do that depends on the leasing pipeline.
And I feel like so far in the call you guys have given a few points of commentary on making it seem like there is that opportunity. I know somebody asked if Sephora had prompted new leases and you said the discussions at least the answer was yes.
But I guess, is there any other stats, Steve, that you or anybody else could provide to talk about the leasing pipeline? And when you do have a vacancy or a location that you're trying to backfill, like is there necessarily competition for that space?
I get that it totally depends on the exact center in the space, but is there generally competition? Or how are you seeking that new user and like how deep is that pool that you're going to, and who's receptive to that interest in the space?
Stephen Yalof
Yeah, well, again, if there's competition, there is -- there's always going to be competition from the incumbent in the space who wants to stay. And, it's going to be up to us in our leasing strategy to try and fill that space with either a better-producing retailer that adds a tremendous amount of variety.
As we look at the retailers that are available to choose from that want to be in our shopping centers, where we were in the past, pure-play outlet, we've now invited other uses, other brands, other types of tenancy into our centers, which have dramatically expanded the addressable market for us to seek new tenants to come in. And that is in the entertainment categories, the food and beverage categories, and in the case of a Sephora or in Ulta categories that really haven't been in this space before, but bring not only a new shopper to our centers, increase the frequency of their visit, and even more importantly, to the earlier point that you made, bring other retailers that might not have considered our space before.
As far as the stats are concerned, what all I can share statistically is that we're seeing retail retailers come to our platform in numbers we haven't seen in quite some time. We're being strategic about who we select to go where while continuing to drive our rent and drive our recovery numbers so we can operate our shopping centers in this environment at the highest possible level while growing our NOI, and I think that we're executing on all of those fronts.
Operator
Our next question is from Mike Mueller with JPMorgan. Please proceed.
Mike Mueller
Yeah, hi. As it relates to acquisitions you've talked about focusing on properties where you can add a lot of value with your platform.
So out of curiosity, what are the types of centers that you don't think work well on the platform that you tend to pass on?
Stephen Yalof
Yeah, Mike, obviously, we're within the outlet sector. That's straight up for what we do.
Our open-air lifestyle centers, similar tenants, similar operations, that's a natural extension. As we think about our adjacencies, when we can expand the retail pie of what we already own and that provides some ability to have attachment area.
There are things like we're not going to do workouts. We really want to drive value creation in anything that we buy.
So we want to try to stick to the retailers that we do business with and try to find those opportunities where our platform can be driven overall.
Mike Mueller
Got it. Okay.
And I apologize if I missed this, but are you working on any, I guess, higher probability development opportunities that we could be hearing about, say, in the next year or so?
Stephen Yalof
We don't like to talk about our pipeline, but we are very active in the marketplace right now, in some interesting new markets that we think we can come in and add. We're an operating company.
I think that that's pretty unique in this space. We're not coming in and then third-partying out our marketing or leasing our operations.
We do all of that stuff ourselves. The fact that we've got such a strong team and such a great track record of operations over here.
At Tanger, there's a number of potential partners that we're in discussions and working within the -- with the opportunity of not only the possibility of buying outright and owning, or in some instances partnering in JV. So there's a number of opportunities that have been presented to us that we might not have seen several years ago had we not executed to the Palm Beach project that we were -- that we're currently working with Clarion on, or the Huntsville, Alabama lifestyle shopping center, which was something that, certainly, a first for us as a platform, but something that we're absolutely know that this operating team could add tremendous value to.
Operator
And our next question is a follow-up from Floris van Dijkum with Compass Point. Please proceed.
Floris van Dijkum
Thanks guys. Just a couple of quick follow-ups.
Your temp percentage historically has been around 10%. Is that still at those elevated or more elevated levels, or is it subsiding closer to the 5%, which I think is what your long-term historical average has been?
Stephen Yalof
Look, temp leasing is a strategy for us. When we brought the temp leasing responsibility in-house to each one of our general managers and all of our shopping centers, we've increased the number of people that are thinking about temp leasing.
Embedded in those temp leasing numbers even at that 10% number is frictional vacancy between a retailer leaving a space and when the new retailer is going to occupy that space, it's incumbent on that management team in each one of our shopping centers to keep that space occupied. And so whether it's a local retailer or one of the seasonal retailers that are national in scope that travel our shopping centers from center to center or space to space, we're going to keep that space occupied.
So if there's a one square-foot of vacancy or opportunity in our center, we're going to try and keep that occupied by a temp retailer. And I would say, we're doing a great job of increasing our permanent occupancy.
But again, there's always going to be some frictional vacancy and we're always going to keep that occupied.
Floris van Dijkum
Right. And it doesn't quite get to the answer I was hoping to get, but I understand the strategy.
So another question, perhaps in terms of your, how you define your 95% retention, which is very high, obviously. When you downsize a tenant, does that count as a retained tenant?
Stephen Yalof
No. When we downsize a tenant and move them to another location, it's a new lease, it's a new deal.
Operator
Our next question is a follow-up from Caitlin Burrows with Goldman Sachs. Please proceed.
Caitlin Burrows
Hi. This might be able to be answered when we go back to the transcripts, but in case it's not, I figured I'd ask again.
But just in terms of Express, but I think, it might actually be more related to Rue21, what you were talking about. It sounds like they had all the original stores in the portfolio, it sounds like you took a total of four back, or got four back.
But the other Rue stores, it sounds like maybe they closed and they're reopening. But can you just flush that out a little bit about where you started kind of in between?
And then the outcome later in the year, the moving pieces there.
Stephen Yalof
Well, the Express stores, all but one remained open. The Rue stores, all closed of the 20.
Two, we took back. The other 18, over half of them have reopened already, the balance of which will open by the end of the year.
Caitlin Burrows
Got it. Thank you.
Operator
With no further questions in the queue, we will conclude today's conference. You may disconnect your lines at this time.
And thank you for your participation.