Ninety One Plc

Ninety One Plc

180.00
GBX
+2.20
(+1.24%)
201.39BMarket Cap
Jun 03Next Earn

Q2 FY2027 · Earnings Call TranscriptNovember 16, 2026

Hendrik

Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. Welcome to the Ninety One interim results presentation for the half year to 30 September 2026.

I will highlight the key numbers before moving to the business review. Kim McFarland, our finance director, will then present the financial review.

I will then conclude before we take questions. Those of you participating through the webcast can submit questions during the presentation by accessing the chat function at the bottom of your screen.

Please state your organization and name as well. We are delighted to report growth in assets under management, revenue, and earnings.

Assets under management grew by 19% to 181.4 billion. We experienced net outflows of 4.2 billion.

This was not anticipated at year-end. Adjusted earnings per share, our preferred earnings metric, increased by 5%, while basic earnings per share, impacted by accounting treatment related to the Sanlam transaction, declined by 8%.

The dividend per share was lifted in line with the adjusted earnings per share. Our operating margin expanded to 32.5%.

Through many market cycles, Ninety One has managed to grow from start-up into the global business it is today. In our original home market, we continue to serve a wide range of investors and their advisors.

In the rest of the world, we serve the largest and most sophisticated asset owners and asset platforms, as well as a select group of financial advisors. We are a resilient business, and we have ample opportunity to grow market share in the years to come.

Average assets under management increased by 29% to 179.6 billion from 139.7 in the comparable period in 20- in the 2026 financial year. Top-line growth and cost management improved the operating margin.

Against our expectations, we suffered net outflows. This was driven by two factors.

Firstly, investment underperformance in two distinct but important categories. Secondly, positive but slower than anticipated funding in areas where we expected inflows and where performance has been good, for example, emerging markets and commodities and resources.

We continue to win in these areas. We are transforming the business for a fast-changing operating environment.

The AI revolution, the changing geopolitical landscape, and the intensifying sustainability challenges are driving change. Our priorities are clear.

We must focus on investment performance and invest in talent and technology to be future fit for this world of change. We have operated in positive but hard-to-beat equity market conditions, impacted by a changing sentiment and rising cost of long-term funding.

The consequences of the repricing in bond markets and the nervousness in credit markets have been partially felt, but the tussle between the bulls and bears will be with us for some time to come. We anticipate growth in demand for income products at this stage of the cycle.

The Sanlam transaction and the growth of our credit capabilities have given us new impetus to pursue these opportunities. As previously predicted, emerging markets have continued to increase their relevance to global investors.

As the relative performance of this class holds or improves, we expect investor interest to grow. In spite of the continued rise of passive, we believe that opportunities for good active management will increasingly present themselves.

Forward-looking firms, including us, are investing in their digital capabilities to ensure that they will be able to deliver their offerings in tokenized form in due course. We are fully prepared.

Our industry remains intensely competitive. Asset owners remain focused on costs and are constantly raising the bar for external allocations.

It is interesting to note that although the US, and specifically technology stocks, performed well over the past 3 years, emerging markets have quietly kept pace, despite the Chinese market lagging substantially. When we look at fixed income performance, the strength of emerging markets is even more pronounced.

Over the reporting period, they delivered positive returns, while developed market bonds and traded credit recorded losses. Over 3 years, the differentials are even greater, with emerging market bonds in hard and local currency, as well as emerging market investment-grade credit, delivering double to 3 times the performance outcomes of their peers in developed markets.

Although these are some of the most concentrated equity markets since the establishment of Ninety One, active managers should be aware that there have been similar periods of sustained concentration in the past. This is an update of a slide used to evidence the renewed interest in active emerging market investing.

We expect the inflows to remain positive into emerging markets, and that active will increase its share of flows. The AI boom and a range of other factors are currently muting the upswing for emerging market investing relative to previous cycles, as you can see from the chart.

Here, you can see how assets under management have grown since 2023. While we have experienced net outflows of 4.2 billion over the half year, we added 13.8 billion to assets under management through portfolio growth.

We generated net inflows into emerging market equity strategies. However, these were offset by net outflows from global, South African, and international equity strategies.

Multi-asset experienced net outflows as a consequence of the South African equity underperformance. Fixed income was broadly flat, as net inflows into South African money market income and emerging market blended strategies were offset by outflows from emerging market corporate strategies.

Alternatives generated modest net inflows. Here, the pipeline is building, but as private credit asset raising takes time.

We hope to close two new fundraisings in the second half of this year. The South African fund platform continued to see net inflows.

Europe was the only client group to record net inflows, mainly into Asian and emerging market equities, and emerging market blended fixed income strategies. Asia Pacific net outflows were driven by a small number of large institutional clients reducing their exposure to global equities.

Our joint venture, Ninety One Asia, had a good start and has recorded positive net inflows, but unfortunately, the global equity redemptions from the region, not in the JV, hides this. In the Americas, net outflows were primarily driven by the fact that the quality style had difficulty keeping pace with broad benchmarks.

Our team has done what they promised clients, but after many years of outperformance, the quality style will remain in a tough place while markets remain obsessed with growth stocks. In Africa, net outflows were largely caused by underperformance in domestic equity mandates.

That I have for some time been talking about a turnaround in the UK. I confidently state that this is happening.

Unfortunately, certain mandates did not manage to fund ahead of the end of the reporting period. This client group has a pipeline well in excess of 2.5 billion of won but unfunded mandates, some of which may even fund later in the year, post the financial year-end.

Some of our equity strategies struggled with performance over the reporting period, either for stylistic or stock selection reasons. The style-driven result is what it is, and we encourage our team to stick to what works in the long term.

This is a time to support them, not to pressurize them. Where stock selection has been the issue, we are working hard to improve ourselves.

This includes process improvements, personnel and leadership changes where necessary. Our teams are experienced and capable, and are tenaciously clawing back underperformance.

The commercial outcome will be determined by markets as much as by our own efforts. We are actively investing in new talent and technology to build and strengthen our propositions.

This is a humbling profession, and very few houses and teams get it right all the time. It is noteworthy to point to our competitive 3-year numbers, given the current momentum in emerging markets.

I'm glad to report that performance is good across that platform. I want to highlight that neither the Sanlam transaction nor any internal issues caused any of the above-mentioned factors.

Sanlam Investment Management was predominantly a fixed income business, and we have done well in this asset class. We remain firmly focused on the long-term performance delivery.

We have successfully completed the Sanlam transaction on time and on budget. This included people and systems integration.

This transaction has shifted our weight to emerging markets. It has also increased our proportional revenues from fixed income at a time when the equity bull market looks rather mature.

As we do with all our partners, we have invested heavily into the Sanlam relationship. Evidence of strength of this relationship is that we are in the process of joining forces in Namibia with Sanlam and its partner Allianz, with whom Ninety One already has a strong relationship.

We have received approval from the Competition Commission, and now await final regulatory approval from NAMFISA, the Namibian regulator. This will bring an additional N$40 billion, or £2 billion, under management.

Our domestic efforts in the Middle East have been slowed down by the unfortunate outbreak of war, but our teams are resilient, and we were on the ground throughout. We are launching our first domestic strategy in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia with local funding that came after the end of the reporting period.

We have an active pipeline, some of which should convert in the second half of the year. Ninety One Asia is off to an excellent start.

The investment professionals, alternative and long-only, are now working as one team and benefiting from the insight and access of our partners. They have performed well and generated good net inflows.

Overall, our in-region platforms are adding value and supporting our position as a global leader in emerging markets investing. We made the decision to focus our private credit efforts on emerging market.

We therefore exited our European credit opportunities effort by partnering with the New York-headquartered Sound Point Capital Management. Our emerging markets debt business is close to finalizing external seeding on a high-potential hedge fund strategy.

Our emerging markets private credit business has good momentum and excellent performance after substantial investing during the previous financial year. We expect to see the first close of two new infrastructure vehicles in the final quarter of this year.

On the public market side of the business, we are making knowledge and insight sharing between teams much easier by creating a single digitized and AI-enabled research platform, while still encouraging investment teams to execute according to their unique philosophies and processes. Finally, we have made significant strides on getting our data organized for the AI era.

While we are not yet able to show tangible productivity gains, we are confident that this will come. Let me talk about our AI efforts.

For AI adoption, we remain at 9 out of 10. In September, about 90% of our people were active users of Claude.

This figure compares with 50% 6 months earlier. There was a time when 50% was considered respectable in the industry.

Notably, a quarter of our users work in Claude Code, where people literally change how tasks get done on desk. In experimentation, we have moved from 7 to 9 out of 10.

Innovation is proliferating. In the investment teams, we are conducting about a dozen material initiatives.

Our operations and client groups are running many more. Ultimately, what we want to achieve is the creation of commercially relevant AI solutions at scale.

In data, we have moved from 4 to 5 out of 10. We know that clean, accessible, and complete data is non-negotiable.

We have hired additional specialists in modeling, engineering, and governance to help harness our data effectively. The transformation score stays at 3.

The test is whether AI is changing and improving what we provide our clients in investment outcomes, experience, and service. Internally, yes, AI is helping us deal with greater volumes.

That is useful, but not necessarily transformational. Smart AI usage is fundamental to our future fitness, and we must succeed on this front to add credence to our claim that we are building the investment manager of the future.

We are fully committed to this goal. I now hand over to our finance director, Kim McFarland, to report in more detail on the group's financial performance.

Thank you, Kim.

Kim McFarland

Thank you, Hendrik. I'm here to present a set of strong financial results for the period ending 30 September 2026.

I'd like to highlight that our core operating business has again produced a solid outcome. The results for this period include the full impact of the Sanlam take-on, so many of the comparatives are not like-for-like.

However, we are showing growth in adjusted operating profit after successfully completing the integration of the Sanlam Investment Management business. As we issued shares for the purchase, the best reflection of our results will be the adjusted EPS, and this increased by 5% to 8.8p.

Noting this, management fees increased by 21% and adjusted operating expenses by 17%, resulting in the core business recurring results increasing by 30% on the prior period to £106.7 million. Management fees were at £351 million.

This is a result of the increase in the average AUM from £139.7 billion to £179.6 billion, alongside a decline in the average management fee rate to 39 basis points from 41.5 basis points. As mentioned, this AUM growth was because of the take-on of the Sanlam Investment business.

The key reason for the decline in the fee rate has also been the take-on of the Sanlam assets, which were at a lower rate. To note, for the prior period to March 2026, the average fee rate was at 40 basis points.

I did say at our final results in June that I anticipated the average fee rate for the year to be between 38 to 40 basis points, and so a 39 basis point fee rate is aligning to our stated view of a decline between 1 to 2 basis points per annum. Adjusted operating expenses of £244.3 million includes the interest expenses on the lease liabilities for our office premises and the full bonus accruals, but excludes non-operating expenses.

The adjusted operating profit of £117.8 million is up 19% from the prior period. Performance fees declined to £12.1 million.

Other income, or rather loss here, is negligible and is mainly a number of fair value adjustments on seed investments and FX movements on the balance sheet. The adjusted profit margin increased from 32.1 to 32.5%.

To reiterate, the adjusted earnings per share increased by 5% to 8.8p. Ninety One's profit before tax after considering the non-operating adjustments increased by 9% to £111.9 million.

For the non-operating adjustments, adjusted net interest is the interest earned on corporate bank balances. At the interims, the share scheme is generally a net expense.

This is largely reflecting the amortization impact from the prior-year credits where staff bonuses were allocated to Ninety One shares. At the year-end, we have a better understanding of the share scheme credit with the allocation of the annual staff bonuses to Ninety One shares.

Remember, we fully expense the bonus payments within adjusted operating expenses. IFRS requires the amortization of bonus-related share awards over 4 years, which is included in the share scheme expense.

The corporate-related items are not considered as operating expenses. The amortization of the intangible asset is as a result of the Sanlam transaction.

This is now the full 6 months deduction. The effective tax rate for the year was 29.2%, up from 25% in the prior period.

This was largely driven by a large number of non-deductible expenses, including the amortization of the intangible assets. There are some other smaller contributing factors, but we expect this higher effective tax rate going forward.

The above factors resulted in a profit after tax of £79.2 million, up 3% from the prior period. This analysis summarizes the absolute movement in the adjusted operating profit from H1 2026 to H1 2027.

It clearly shows that management fees increased, but this increase was partially offset by the lower performance fees and other income items, and the increase in employee remuneration and business expenses, all resulting in the adjusted operating profit increasing to £117.8 million. This is the analysis of the movement in adjusted operating expenses.

Adjusted operating expenses increased by 17% to £244.3 million. Employee remuneration represents 63% of the total expense base.

In the prior period, it was 64%. Increased by £19 million, or 14%, to £153.1 million.

This was driven by an increase in fixed remuneration, consistent with the increase in headcount from Sanlam, and annual inflationary increases, as well as an increase in variable remuneration in line with increased adjusted operating profit. Over 50% of employee remuneration remains variable, and the resulting compensation ratio was 42.3%, down from 43.6% in the prior period.

Business expenses increased by 22% to £91.2 million. There was no change to period-on-period split of business expenses, and technology remains the largest business expense along with the largest increase, and this was driven by increase in costs incurred for software and external IT services.

The increase in third-party administration was driven by the additional activity from the Sanlam business. Office costs increased driven primarily by the move into the new Cape Town offices.

Included in other items are increases in consulting fees, marketing, travel costs, and general expenses. The costs are now a clear reflection of the cost base looking ahead for the next 6 months.

We will expect the business expenses to continue to be impacted by inflation and ongoing technology spend. This is showing the business expenses and total expenses as a percentage of average AUM in basis points over a 5.5-year period.

The adjusted operating profit margin over the period is also reflected here, and has remained in the range of 31 to 35%. This now has the full impact of Sanlam, and the scale benefit is being shown here, especially when looking at the improved adjusted operating margin and the darker line there, this being the total expenses in basis points of average AUM.

Business expenses as a percentage of average AUM have also declined by the growth in the denominator. Ninety One's qualifying capital was £332.4 million at the end of September 2026.

In line with our dividend policy, the board has proposed an interim dividend of 6.3p. This is an increase of 5% in line with the increase in adjusted EPS, the best reflection of the results of this business.

After this dividend payment, there will be an estimated capital surplus of £147.1 million, and this will result in a capital coverage of 220%. We continued with our buyback program in the period, and this resulted in another return of capital of £25 million and a reduction of 11.7 million shares to 993.5 million shares at the end of September 2026.

This last slide is showing the movement in our share count since the listing. At the listing in 2020, we had 922.7 million shares in issue.

In June 2025, we issued 13.7 million shares, and then a further 112 million shares in February 2026 for the Sanlam transaction. However, under our buyback programs, which started before the Sanlam share issue, we've bought back 59.3 million shares, such that at the close on 12 November last week, we had 989.1 million shares in issue.

This buyback program will continue under the approval of the board and at the agreed share price. In line with our capital-light model since listing over 6 years ago, we have now returned over 70% of our initial market capitalization to shareholders in the form of buybacks and dividends.

On this final point, I'll now hand you back to Hendrik.

Hendrik

Thank you, Kim. Although we delivered increased revenue and adjusted earnings per share, we are not satisfied.

We must do better. Our immediate priorities are to deliver better investment performance and make Ninety One future fit.

The future fit objective is all about talent and technology. We will remain disciplined as far as costs and capital are concerned, and we will continue to capitalize on our strength in emerging markets.

In an uncertain environment, our strategy remains consistent. Our entrepreneurial drive and openness to innovation will create new opportunities.

We are building the active investment manager of the future by deploying a client-focused, people-centric, tech- and AI-enabled, and capital-light business model. We relish the prospect of building a better firm for the benefit of all our stakeholders over the long term.

This concludes our formal presentation. We will now move to Q&A.

If you have a question and have not yet submitted it, please do so through the chat function at the bottom of your screen, and identify yourself and your organization. Thank you very much.

Let's start with questions. Varney, do we start in the room or online?

Operator

In the room.

Hendrik

Angeliki Bairaktari. Nice to have you back.

Angeliki Bairaktari

Good morning. It's Angeliki Bairaktari from JP Morgan.

Thank you for taking my questions. Just a couple from me, please.

Thank you for the additional color on the 4.2 billion outflows that you had. Can you tell us a little bit, based on what you're seeing on the ground, both in South Africa, but also in the global franchise, what is the outlook for flows in the second half?

Could we hope for a better performance there, potentially even inflows, or is that sort of too early to hope for that? Then a second question with regards to the management fee rate.

You previously gave this guidance of 38 to 40 basis points, given now those outflows concentrated in equities and multi-asset that tend to be higher margin. What are your expectations for the evolution of the management fee rate in the remainder of the year?

Perhaps a bit more broadly with regards to sort of the conversations that you're having with clients. Are you seeing this trend of reallocation out of developed markets into emerging markets taking place?

There's been so many geopolitical events again this year. In the beginning of the year, there was a hope that we would finally see EM coming back in full force, but that is not really reflected in your flows, any color there would be helpful.

Hendrik

Thank you. Thank you, Angeliki, and again, welcome back after your period off.

Let me start off from the back to front, it's probably easier. Emerging markets, I've shown you the chart where the actual flows, particularly the active flows, have not yet taken off.

I think we should all go and read Ruchir Sharma's article in this morning's FT, where we have an equity world where all equity investors think they're American investors. That essentially is still driven by the SpaceX, Anthropic, all the fantastic innovation that's happening in America.

That is still the case, and therefore, the bar for a diversifier or a wider investment, and again, I've shown you in fixed income by how much emerging markets have already outperformed. Yet, the bulk of the active flows haven't moved.

I think it will in due course, but given the fact that the outperformance of the US was so much, and given the geopolitical uncertainties, capital tends to stay home for longer. Of course, given the underperformance of China, which is essentially the counterbalance, largely driven by geopolitics, not by lack of innovation.

I was just there last week, the innovation is enormous what's going on there, and the technological leap forward is going to continue, and you can feel it either by investing in it or feeling it in your car companies back home being competed out of existence. I think that shift will come, it's a slower shift because of the reasons I mentioned.

We are not going to divert from that, because in the end, a diverse portfolio, and there is evidence that diversification benefits are building up in this world, which is slightly more, I wouldn't say decoupled, but less integrated. We will keep going on that basis.

I do think we could have probably won, a few balls bounced in the debt side that if we had won them, the numbers would look very different, but it's not a flood yet, and it's not the kind of bull market you saw two, three cycles ago. I think that's clear.

You should be cautious when you model that, but having looked at Ashmore's results and others that are more transparent about their emerging markets, you can see the turn is actually happening. Second thing is fee.

I think our fee expectations were met 100%. We told you last time it's going to be sort of 38 to 40.

We got there, and noting that the Sanlam fee, because it was a large book, it was a $23 billion, $24 billion book, that fee was obviously lower than our average fee, and therefore, the fact that the fee stayed quite close tells you that also some of the mandates or some of the outflows, even though they were in equities, were bulk clients reducing weight, and therefore, not as expensive on the fee level. We stick to our 100 basis points, maybe 250 basis points fee pressure for the time being, although the fee debate is shifting towards private markets.

There's no doubt, even though the headline fee in private market hasn't shifted, clients asking for bigger co-investment allocations, which then makes their average fee a lot lower. Don't be fooled by the 2 and 20 or the 2 and 10 fee structures, because actually, next to the funds, there are allocations coming through which are essentially low-cost.

I think the fee debate is shifting elsewhere, but we still have to prove value, and ours is more becoming a percentage of alpha, which means alpha is the challenge rather than fee. I would say if you look at it the next few years, I'd worry less about fee, more about alpha and operating margin, in other words, using technology to be more efficient, less labor-intensive would be the way active managers are probably going, and you've seen these phenomenal results by the quants.

Now, this market was good for quants last while, they also have a cycle. Have I answered all your questions?

I think just the one thing on performance, which you probably didn't ask, is we said in two categories we had performance challenges, some of which had started at beginning of the year, and we thought weren't that serious, and then actually the Gulf War, the Iran war exacerbated that, is in global and international equities. One was style, the quality style, which wasn't supposed to stay with the market, but doesn't generate inflows if you don't stay with the market, and sometimes gets weights against it because the clients feel the regime has changed, but they've actually done what they're supposed to do, and right now they're doing pretty well.

This is going to be a great week for them again, given where markets are. I think the market-relative global equity strategy, we have 4Factor, which is a very large platform, that platform has done very well in emerging markets.

On the global side, made a few stock selection errors, and stock selection errors can be quite expensive because the market moves stocks far, and therefore, your alpha gets slightly depleted, and that makes clients either downweight or not buy. You see, the two things that work, remember in an active manager, you have quite a significant inflow and a significant outflow all the time.

If the ratio between them changes, suddenly your number looks kind of big, and it may not be that big because you have to close the jaws from two sides. Then finally, in South Africa, I think we should've just been better, and we are making all our efforts there on the equity side to get our mojo back.

I think that can be recovered quite quickly. Our fixed income platform has done very, very well.

That's the story.

Angeliki Bairaktari

Any early thoughts for H2 flows?

Hendrik

H2 flows, as I said, I think in the South African one, you can probably recover faster. On the global side, it depends I think how much fixed income we win, whether our infra credit fundraisings are good, and whether our performance clawbacks happen as expected.

Because firstly, once you start clawing back as we have done, you hold the outflows, and then we have to really win big on the emerging market side. I'm so hurt after the last signal I gave you that flows would be good.

We were budgeting for pretty big inflows, and I didn't think I was just hoping, I think it was real. I'm very cautious to promise anything, but I think it could be better.

This was not a good experience, and we are a diverse business, and that is the strength, and very rarely do we have three things or two categories underperforming at the same time. Let's see.

What we do know is you don't switch the inflow on immediately once you recover your numbers. You've got to convince clients that you're actually sustainable again.

I would be cautious. I wouldn't just go back with a massive inflow in the second half.

I'm pretty confident that what we're doing is right. We've been here many times before, and you've got to be able to bat from the back foot as well as the front foot.

Ryan. You were the only one right on flows.

I thought you were wrong first half. I hope you are not going to predict more of that now.

Raein Karim

I don't think I've ever been congratulated for having a negative number, but anyway. Raein Karim from Cavendish.

Three questions if I may. The first was just on the JV, just if we could get a bit more color on how that's progressing, how you feel that can evolve, and what kind of cash costs you can foresee and for us to be thinking about going forward.

The second was just around trying to clarify a comment that Kim made on the cost base, just whether the first half is a good number to annualize, or whether we need to put some inflation on top of that. Then the third was just if you had any guidance on performance fees.

I know it's a tricky number, but that would be helpful.

Hendrik

I think let me do the two, and then Kim can talk about costs. I just want to say efforts to reduce costs sometimes cost in the short term, you get the benefit the following year.

Kim can answer that. Why don't you just give the answer now on costs?

Kim McFarland

I did mention that we saw the second half that we've sort of got the Sanlam cost bases in there. We have spent extra during the integration through the period.

I think if I look at the base, we're going to be very conscious of costs, look at them to capture them, but I do see an increased inflation coming through, and I think the second thing is IT spend, and I did mention that as well. There's, to Hendrik's point, we're going to have to spend a bit there to obviously get the benefits in the long term.

I'm not seeing a decrease in costs in the second half.

Hendrik

Your consultants to help you organize your databases and that, we should've we should've done that 7, 10 years ago when it was really cheap. That that costs now, and you burn a lot of tokens and that to to to kind of change the model.

We're not going to stop, because what we can't do is go into the future with with a a sort of 20- 2020s business model when you move into the 2030s. I think that's the near term, but I think we will be able to run at at at better margins down the line.

The your other question, sorry, you you had two two others.

Raein Karim

The JV.

Hendrik

The JV. There's no additional costs there because, remember, our partners put in capital as well, it's just putting two things together.

What we are really generating good alpha at the moment, given the additional perspective and knowledge. We are also starting to see, not yet very big, but we're starting to see reach or access to clients which we previously didn't have, and I think we're going to have a few wins from that region.

Then second last, there's very high performance fee potential in the way that is structured, but right now with Asian markets being under pressure because of the kind of AI trade unwinding, I think it's going to take a bit of time. One of our key products there is a crossover vehicle, which brings pre-listings to us earlier, and then benefiting from the listing.

Now there are things like Moonshot and other things coming out, which will be spectacular, then they should generate really good performance fees if markets are going to get excited about IPOs. What we've seen in Hong Kong lately is the IPO window is largely closed for the moment.

I think that's into the new year. Some of it might come in the last quarter, but I wouldn't bank on it.

I'm very, very excited in particular what we're doing in AI experimentation in a smaller unit, where we could move faster to innovate and create, in your big shop, you have to negotiate everything with your clients, you have to be very transparent, whereas in a smaller unit, you have fewer stakeholders to convince that you could experiment, and I'm very excited about that. By and large, both, call it joint ventures we have done or partnerships we've done and announced in the last year, both turned out, in my opinion, very, very successful, and you'll see the benefit of it down the line, including the Sanlam.

It takes a long time to warm up that machine. That is actually happening, and I expect firstly, we didn't lose as much third-party money as we expected, that was a positive, because remember the third-party book is loose when you do a deal like that.

I think the machine will start producing bread-and-butter flows, which will be very supportive of our business down the line.

Raein Karim

Performance fees?

Hendrik

Oh, performance fees. I spoke about the performance fees coming out of the joint venture.

On other performance fees, it really depends by and large on I don't think you should get your hopes up, but the quality side is much more a positive beta story, where there's performance fees, even if they do well relative to the market, they're not going to earn massive performance fees. I think in the multi-asset, if we turn some of that, we could make.

I wouldn't get excited, it's a million here and there, it's with the same number of last year, a little more. Where the performance fee potential is in longer term in the private markets and in Ninety One Asia with the crossover.

There's significant performance fees equal to probably what we have currently as total performance fees in the shop. Let's let that happen first.

It's not going to happen soon. Okay.

Anything else?

Kim McFarland

No.

Hendrik

Varney?

Operator

We've got a couple of questions from the webcast. First one is from Matthew Pouncett from Laurium Capital.

I think one of your questions, Matthew, has already been answered on annual average fee rate going forward, but your other question is: what was the reduction in average management fee rate excluding the impact of the Sanlam take-on assets?

Kim McFarland

I can answer that if you want. I can answer that because we do the analysis of how the fee rate is built up, and the impact was probably just over one basis point impact on those particular numbers.

Operator

Okay. Next question from Siphelele Mdudu.

The question is: you said outflows were against expectations. What did the pipeline look like in March versus what actually happened?

What is the won but not yet funded pipeline today, and how have October and November gone? Have any further redemptions been notified?

Hendrik

I don't, as a matter of principle, comment on post-period to say that, but given where markets have gone, it's obviously not bull market territory. We feel quite solid about that, and the won but unfunded at year-end was 2.5 billion, some of which have funded, all of which may not fund for the full year.

We were a bit unlucky that some of that could have come in and made the outflow experience look a bit better. We still have to see, and that's important, we still have to see how we do during the course of the year, because in the end, this is about how well you perform, particularly when you're on the back foot.

Yes, it's better than the first half.

Operator

No further questions.

Hendrik

Thank you very much. No more questions from here?

You've all exhausted yourselves. You listened to us.

We look forward to seeing you at the end of the year with better news. Thank you very much.

Kim McFarland

Thank you.

Hendrik

Thank you.