Nick Teh
Hi everyone. Welcome to the analyst briefing.
You've heard the presentation during the media briefing, so as usual, we'll go straight to Q&A. The first question from Jayden from Macquarie.
Jayden, you can go ahead and unmute yourself and ask your question. Jayden.
Jayden Vantarakis
Hey, can you hear me okay, Nick?
Nick Teh
Yep.
Jayden Vantarakis
Great. Thanks a lot for the opportunity.
I just wanted to ask a little bit around the guidance. I think first of all, you've got sort of mid single-digit growth, which seems to be implied from the outlook for rates and loans, etc.
Just wanted to sort of check if you had any thoughts specifically around sort of fees, because it sort of implies that the fee trajectory is going to slow a little bit. If I look at the growth in the net new money and the wealth performance this year, I'm just wondering if there's something you're seeing that's giving you some pause, and the reason why it's sort of implying a bit of softer guidance?
That was the first question. The second thing is if you could comment at all around sort of deposit competition, because some of your peers have sort of said that's heated up, but if you look at your performance, obviously, your margins have been really strong.
Just wondering if you're seeing any sort of pick up on the deposit competition side, or anything we should be aware of? Those are the two questions I wanted to ask, and thanks very much.
Tan Su Shan
Okay. On the non-NII, we said that if the markets are good, because a lot of it depends on both volatility and volumes.
If you have good volatility and hopefully more upside than downside, and good volumes, then this year we grew by double digits, hopefully next year we'll continue to grow, all being well, by the low double digits. If the markets melt down, and sentiment turns negative and volumes dry up, then it's hard to go against the market, right?
Then we're looking at sort of high single-digit growth. That's just, I think, being a little bit prudent.
You're right. Look, underlying, the client growth is solid, the net new money is solid, and what is also solid is the fact that the franchise is now pivoting towards a stronger recurring income type of shape of the portfolio.
More discretionary, in-house discretionary, third-party discretionary. That percentage of AUM has been growing very nicely.
On the retail wealth side, as I've always said, it's the regular savings plans, it's just getting more and more consumers onboard, and they save a little bit more every year, and they give us their CPFB accounts, etc. That's all snowballing quite nicely, and it's a slow but gradual accumulation of fees at the lower retail end.
Then the fees for transaction banking is actually growing quite well, and that speaks to us now winning a lot more mandates for transaction services, and for trade, right? It's cross-border cash payments, it's trade services, it's supply chain financing, it's custody growth.
It's also the fact that we're one of the few banks that can tokenize deposits, that can tokenize gold. That, again, it's the velocity of flow.
If you win a lot more operating accounts, you naturally get more flow, you naturally get more flow, more CASA, and more fees. Then that speaks to your other question around deposit growth and deposit competition.
I will kick off and I'll let my colleagues chime in. There, I think earlier in the year We saw some of our peers reducing their loan rates, whether it was on mortgages or some large corporate loans.
We deliberately lost some market share, and we held our own, and we kept our deposit rates high. We kept our frontline rates high.
We didn't cut our deposit rates, and we won market share in the last two quarters, especially in the last quarter, because we were hopefully, I guess, quite prescient in predicting that rates were going to rise, but also we wanted to increase our market share deliberately. We did a lot of work, the teams did a lot of work there to both gate deposits and win new mandates, both for consumer and for wealth and for corporate.
I think that's worked out well. Going forward, a lot of work being done still on mapping out elasticity of deposit rates using both AI, agentic use cases, and also taking advantage of any volatility in the markets.
By the way, we've seen a lot of that to continue to hedge our interest rate going forward, grabbing whatever high rates we see. On that, I'll open up to my colleagues to say anything on deposits.
I'll add on.
Han Kwee Juan
I think deposits-wise, we have been quite good at gathering CASA, and so if you look at the CASA performance for this quarter, it's good because we are getting new mandates and bringing in live transactions. Our acquisition has also seen customers funding the accounts earlier, we've got good momentum on acquisition.
It's a combination of new to firm, catching deposits, this new mandate that we get from current customers, operating cash mandates. These are the ones that are helping us to get the deposit in, and then this is something that we will continue to just work on, because it's a machinery, you just have to win and then implement and keep going on that basis.
Yeah.
Shee Tse Koon
I guess on the fee side, the one thing I would like to call out is, that from a wealth management perspective, I don't think we should only always just look at one quarter per se. I think we need to look at it in a cumulative fashion, right?
Particularly when we had actually a record quarter last quarter. If you look at nine months, actually it's been very strong.
Nine months versus nine months, right, on the wealth fee side, we've grown north of 20%, right? Then when we look at what the fuel is for such performance, a lot of that has to be still the acquisition of new customers, as well as the deepening of that in getting net new money.
Q3, we've had a very, very strong, in fact a record net new money quarter. That would mean that actually there's a lot of dry powder.
Building on what Su Shan said, right, of course with that dry powder, depending on how the markets go, that will always be one factor. Having said that, we have also over the years been diversifying the revenue stream coming from our wealth business, which would include actually a pretty sizeable growth in our discretionary portfolio management, a reasonable growth as well in other areas in terms of our funds distribution, which in and of itself will have some level of trailer fees, right?
At the same time, there's always also our insurance momentum that has been very, very strong this year. With the increase in client base, the dry powder there, I do think we have what it takes to do well, barring any market meltdown.
Nick Teh
Okay. Thanks.
I think the next question is from Harsh from J.P. Morgan.
Harsh, please go ahead.
Harsh Wardhan Modi
Hi. Thanks for this.
Two questions. One is on capital planning, let's say over next 3 years.
Immediate-term question is how much of CET1 have you recouped in last 5 weeks from end of quarter? More broadly, over next couple of years, it seems the NII growth is a bit more RWA growth-linked, the excess CET1 generation has come off.
In that regard, how do we think about the regular divi? Do we get that 6 cent pick-up this year in fourth quarter, and then that's it, then we kind of stabilize at 72 cents?
Also the capital return, we have five more quarters to go, but once that 75 cents is paid, do we have scope of those numbers continuing or any other sort of buyback amount getting repaid? How do we think about broader capital management till, let's say, 2028?
Thank you. That's one question.
Second is on MAS had a statement on Friday, I think last Friday, that Singapore-based banks should look to rethink the relationship with companies and clients related to haze. Both at a corporate and private bank, is there any meaningful impact for DBS?
Thank you.
Tan Su Shan
I'll kick off and maybe I'll get Sok Hui or Phil to add in. Our fully phased-in CET1 ratio is 14% and post the op risk multiplier reduction, it goes up to 14.1%.
14.1, that means excess capital above 13% is about $5 billion. We are still fully committed to fully distributing the capital returns, which is 15 cents per quarter committed till end of 2027.
On the buybacks of the $3 billion, we've spent about 0.4, we've got $2.6 billion left. It'll be opportunistic.
If the markets are really really bad, we'll use it. If for some reason we can't finish using it, we'll find some other ways of returning it.
For example, that means if you have to extend the capital returns dividend beyond 2027, we'll ask the board to deliberate next year, right? Our ordinary dividend growth will be funded purely by earnings growth.
There, we are really building the franchise, as Harsh, for structural growth in terms of number of clients, volumes for both deposit and loans, in terms of fee growth for wealth, FIG, and GTS, and cost-delta reductions. We've been successful, and we will hope to continue to demonstrate success there.
Our AI agentic workflows are kicking in. We can capacitize now for growth.
I spoke about it earlier on, the fact that our cost delta is plus 2.something percent versus plus 8 before. Yet, we've done with that delta a lot of foundational work and investments around our tech architecture, around our data architecture, around our human training and retraining, and around our agents and human workflows.
All that is not trivial. It's very hard work.
It's meant that the culture we have around being journey-focused and our ability now to shift left, that means going more upstream, means we're in a better position now to bring in new clients, bring in new volumes, and then work that way through the fee gathering. I will let Sok Hui or Phil weigh in on the capital planning side, on the CET1.
Chng Sok Hui
Harsh, I think given that we have got a record nine months, I think we're in a good position, but I think ultimately, it's the board's decision. Depending on what happens, we'll look at the earnings trajectory over a multi-year period before we consider the fourth quarter 2026 dividend.
I think your question was over a slightly longer time horizon, and our planning assumption is that if we can grow profits at about 5% CAGR, we should be able to grow dividends at about 5% CAGR. That's kind of like the long-term direction that we can consider.
Tan Su Shan
Also on RWA, although it looks like it's RWA-led growth, actually, there's also a lot of fee growth, but also, we have a discipline in IBG of asset recycling, and being ROE-focused on whatever we onboard.
Han Kwee Juan
On the palm oil haze, in the way we look at palm oil industry, our approach is that we require the borrowers to align with No Deforestation, No Peat, No Exploitation, which is commonly known as NDPE, and as well as telling them that RSPO certification is a good industry practice, which the client should be on it. On that basis, more than 90% of our portfolio are on RSPO compliance, and everyone is compliant with NDPE.
We have zero tolerance for land clearance by burning. That essentially is our position.
Based on the names that are highlighted, a handful of them are our customers, and we do have some small exposure, but in overall scheme of things, it's really quite small. These customers have consistently shared with us that they are under RSPO, and so that is the certification that we feel is the best practice that the palm oil industry should follow.
Shee Tse Koon
Got
Harsh Wardhan Modi
it.
Shee Tse Koon
Harsh, on the private bank side, riding on what Kee Juan has said, it's similar. Our overarching views and policies would always be aligned with that, right?
Having said that, in the private banking space, you'll find that customers themselves, some of them might be shareholders if there are any of that, right? It depends on shareholders of listed companies for a start.
It's, I would say, to a certain extent, probably another level removed. Also, on the other hand, many of the high-net-worth individuals do have a whole series of different kind of assets and companies, businesses that they run in and of themselves.
Even if they are part of some of these names that are being looked into, it might only be one part of the overall wealth that they have accumulated over the many, many years. There are multiple ways of looking at it.
Having said that, again, our portfolio is very, very diversified. Our clients come from over 110, I think 110 to 120 nationalities.
Again, in the wider scheme of things, not a huge impact at all to the overall PB franchise.
Harsh Wardhan Modi
Great. Thank you for that.
Just wanted to double-check on one thing, Su Shan. 13% CET1, is that a comfort range?
Is that a target? Is there a number that we should think we should get to over let's say 3 to 5 years, or it's just something you want to be close to?
Tan Su Shan
Our target has always been
Chng Sok Hui
13% 13% to
Tan Su Shan
13.5%, and anything above 14% is very comfortable. Between 12.5% and 13.5% is still what we've officially communicated in the past.
Harsh Wardhan Modi
Okay. Thanks so much.
Nick Teh
Thanks. Thanks, Harsh.
Next question from Yong Houng from Citi.
Yong Hong Tan
Hi, Nick. Can you hear me?
Nick Teh
Yep.
Yong Hong Tan
Thanks for the opportunity. This is Yong Houng from Citi.
Just two related questions and one on AUM. Just clarifying on your guidance, if we assume a balance sheet growth at 5%, SORA up by 30 basis points, and based on your sensitivity parameters, net interest income should grow by high single digits for next year.
Just reconciling with your earlier commentaries of mid single digits, is this driven by your expectation for balance sheet growth to slow? A related question is if there's a trade-off between net interest margins and trading income, because if we look at this quarter, the commercial book NIM is down, but NIM is good from markets book.
My question is are we deploying more now given that yields are higher, which is translating to better NIMs, but as a result of that, should we be moderating our expectations on markets trading income, especially if current environment holds? Finally on wealth AUM, net new money was $15 billion, but do you have the split for the FCNR because that will not be repeated, and what is the migration to private banking AUM and the mark-to-market impact?
Yup, these are my questions. Thank you.
Chng Sok Hui
I think there is some natural diversification between our commercial book and our trading book, and that's why we've been giving you the sort of interest rate sensitivities to Sing dollar interest rates and US dollar interest rates. In our commercial book, the US dollar is actually quite balanced, you see that this round, we're giving you NII sensitivity guidance about $10 million per basis point.
That's the sensitivity to Sing dollar interest rates. Then the -2 basis points is to US interest rates, because it's basically the trading book being funded in US dollars.
I think you can make your own assumptions of how much you think rates will rise for both the US dollars and the translation and the pass-through to Sing dollars, because not every rate hike increase will have the same effect and translation into Sing dollars. We also model as rates go up in Sing dollar terms, there may be some outflow into treasury bills, which we have seen in previous periods as well.
On the whole, I think, like I said earlier, if you take third quarter net interest income, you annualized it, add a bit on the net interest income you get from Sing dollar sort of pass-throughs and the growth in loans and deposits, I think you'll arrive at a number that would be shaped below 5%. That's kind of like how we are looking at the net interest income.
Yong Hong Tan
Okay. Because of that deployment into treasury assets, should we be also expecting any offsets from your markets trading books?
Phil Fernandez
This is Phil. Yong Houng, the two are quite separate, yeah.
The markets trading is really the GFM business, that's public markets, you'll see that on the other income line. That's the P&L that we were referring to earlier.
For the hedging business and everything we do with the center, that goes under hedge accounting, and that goes to the net interest income line. When we talk about NII, that includes the impact of interest rates.
Maybe just one comment to add to what Sok Hui said. One other unknown, I would say, is how much deposits are going to grow next year.
This year, we saw about 9%, give or take, across Sing and US blenders, nine months year-to-date. Next year, we think it might go back to mid single digits.
If you've got a different assumption around that, you can always work it into your numbers. That's the other difference to perhaps why you might come up with a higher number than ourselves.
Tan Su Shan
Your question around net new money $15 billion, just to clarify, that $15 billion is without FCNR.
Yong Hong Tan
Okay. Do you have the FCNR number, because if you take...
Chng Sok Hui
It's about $5 billion. As Phil had mentioned in the earlier briefing, net new money is $15 billion for this quarter.
You add in the FCNR, you get to about $20 billion.
Yong Hong Tan
Okay. Then is the migration from mass retail to a private bank AUM, is actually quite chunky as well this quarter, just to reconcile the numbers together?
Phil Fernandez
Sorry, can you repeat the question?
Tan Su Shan
Migration from retail to private.
Shee Tse Koon
No. It's not necessarily a migration.
We do have, of course, clients through the continuum migrating, but if it's just migration, it's left to right pocket, right? When we say net new money, it's really net new money assets coming in from outside funding the account.
It's new clients being acquired, it is existing clients bringing more of their assets in. The movement between segments, that's not add-on to net new money per se.
Yong Hong Tan
Correct. Because if you take out net new money 544 minus 15 minus last quarter 516, the jump is still $13 billion, which is quite sizeable this quarter, especially the market conditions are not as favorable.
Just wondering...
Nick Teh
Yong Houng, you're basically looking at the AUM growing Q-on-Q and then you're putting the $15 billion, you're adding the $5 billion, the rest would be essentially some mark-to-market... Mark-to-market.
Tan Su Shan
Positive mark-to-market, actually.
Shee Tse Koon
Correct. AUM is always a function of net new money plus mark-to-market of what has been deployed into investments.
The strong momentum of our wealth business has always been built on these two pillars, that we have been able to bring net new money consistently now for many, many quarters, and at the same time then, through the advice that we give, have our clients deploy that into investments. It's cash to investments, and thankfully those investments have done well, that's why there's positive mark-to-market.
Yong Hong Tan
Got it. These are all my questions.
Thank you. Also,
Tan Su Shan
the delta is also some existing retail customers going up to wealth, lah.
Shee Tse Koon
Oh yeah, of course. That would also be new to wealth customers, yeah, new to wealth customers.
Meaning to say if we had retail customers who were never in the investment journey, because of our digital wealth nudges and advice through that, some of them then got onto the new investment journey, and we've seen a bit of that as well.
Tan Su Shan
That impacts AUM, but...
Shee Tse Koon
Correct. Net new money, correct.
That impacts AUM, you're right. That impacts AUM if the investments that they have made have grown mark-to-market.
Because to move from deposits to an investment is a left pocket, right pocket as well. They will benefit from the mark-to-market.
Yong Houng, I hope you can see how the dynamics work here, yeah?
Nick Teh
Okay. I think next question from Melissa from Goldman Sachs.
Melissa Kuang
Hi there. Thank you very much for taking my question.
I just have a few questions. Just on the wealth again, the net new money is really robust this quarter, $15 billion.
Do you think this is a new run rate that you can deliver? You have targets for where you want your net new money to be, but just wondering this big step-up that we have seen this quarter, is this a new benchmark at which we will run?
How do you think about net new money in a volatile market? Have you seen historically that it can kind of drop off as well?
Then on my second question, maybe on your expenses, you've given both a CIR ratio and also an absolute kind of growth that you're looking at mid single. Which one should we take a look at in more detail?
Is it the lower of the two, or, if things are better, we get to the 40%, but if not so, then we are benchmarked down as well?
Shee Tse Koon
Okay. Sure, I take the net new money one first, Su Shan?
Tan Su Shan
You take the net new money, yeah.
Shee Tse Koon
All right. On the net new money, whether this is the new momentum, one of the things I'll say is I wouldn't look at it always just purely from a quarter to a quarter, right?
We have to look at it for now, I would say, look at it nine months to nine months. I'll say generally, we do our business planning on an annual basis, right?
What we do need to look at is the momentum that we have been able to build over the last few annual kind of net new money that we've garnered. I guess the positive thing to look at is that we have been very consistent now in the last few years, and this has been a marked increase from, I would say, several years ago.
We can clearly see the momentum growing. I would say that the momentum is good if we look at it from an annual basis and that we believe we are able to sustain and grow.
Part of the reasons is that, if you look at quarter to quarter, it's sometimes dependent on new customers that we bring in. Some will take a bit more time to onboard, or when they get onboarded, they take a bit more time to organize their transfer of their assets.
That's why I wouldn't look at momentum from a quarter-to-quarter basis, but look at it in a more holistic fashion. At the very least in this case, nine months to nine months, and then let's look at it full year to full year.
Tan Su Shan
Then, Melissa, I'll take your cost-income ratio question. Honestly, as a team, I think we're very disciplined around where we spend.
As my chairman likes to say, you can't cut your costs to greatness, we actually do invest for the long term and for the immediate, right? The immediate investments are around things like cybersecurity, things like the data foundation.
We're building a really good foundation for tech, data resiliency, and making us future-ready right now. All that cannot be compromised, and that we spend.
Having said that, the saves that we've noticed, we've been able to save more than we predicted around some of the capacity and the people costs. Why?
Because using these new agentic workflows has really led to capacity and productivity improvements for our staff. Someone who used to cover X number of clients can now cover X plus Y number of clients.
Right, and a client empowered with AI now maybe have one, two, three more products with us. If you get your data architecture and your tech resiliency and your tech architecture right, then you are future-ready for an agentic world where you can use less humans and more agents to do a lot of your work.
Because we have been managing through journeys, we can actually even look at re-working our workflows and our work processes. We call this operating model transformations.
It's really reworking our workflows and shifting left. Shifting left means spending more time, more effort to acquire new customers, to acquire new-to-bank customers, or acquire new-to-product customers, cross-sell if you will, so that we can actually make more money with less effort.
Net-net, I don't manage just to hit a cost-income ratio target. We manage in an agile fashion, because as we use AI, we go, oh, my god, I can save some money there, and then we save.
Then sometimes we say I need to invest in growth. Like we've been investing in wealth, we've been investing in FIG, we've been investing in GTS, in payments.
We don't cut, we don't sting on those, we continue to invest. The wealth teams, they've been hiring a lot of RMs, and we haven't been cutting there, but the existing RMs have been enabled by agentic workflows to help to do more, every RM, every investment counselor can do more.
Similarly in IBG, every RM that we have, even our ops people now can be trained to be more sales-oriented because the agent can do a lot of the operational work today. Our coders, people that used to do low-level production, level one production engineers, they were the production engineers, we don't need so many of them anymore because of AI.
Then they become more level two, level three engineers where there's more domain knowledge, for example, in wealth tech, in trading tech, in our new core banking systems. They have to upskill themselves to go up one level to become more accretive to us, right?
My hope is that whilst I'm not single-mindedly focused on, say, the 40% cost-income ratio, we can show growth with less need to spend so that we can increase productivity across the board.
Nick Teh
We'll move on to the next question from Aakash of UBS.
Aakash Rawat
Great. Thank you for taking my question.
This is Aakash from UBS. I have four different questions.
The first one is...
Nick Teh
I think I'll limit you, in the interest of time, to two.
Aakash Rawat
Two? Okay.
The first one is a set of questions on wealth management. A little bit housekeeping questions, but very quick.
The invested portion of AUM was 59% last quarter. What is that number this quarter?
If you think about the fee to invested AUM margin, that seems to have dipped in Q3 because activity levels were lower, and our calculations is that it's down 14, 15 basis points quarter-on-quarter. How is that trending in November?
Has that number gone back up or is it still down? Then net new money, there doesn't seem to be any impact from China in Q3, China regulations.
Is it possible that we see this in the Q4 numbers? Those would be the three wealth management questions.
Shee Tse Koon
Okay. I think in terms of the investment AUM as compared to total AUM, it's gone up marginally to 59% this quarter, right?
Of course if you look at it the wealth segment includes private bank, right, PB, and then TPC, and then Treasures, right? Typically you see relatively speaking, Treasures would generally hold relatively more deposits than TPC and PB.
These are actually good opportunities we have, right, especially as we work through the wealth continuum, that is actually very good. If you look at really the PB level, it's about 70%.
From there you can see our ability to actually have this dry powder, as I like to call it, to bring them through the continuum. Anyway, notwithstanding, it's 59%, a marginal improvement.
Again, not necessarily unsurprising, because our net new money is very strong. As we always mention, right, the whole engine is about bringing in that new money, and then gradually doing cash-to-investment deployment from that front.
That's why whilst net new money has gone up, we're still able to hold this ratio and have it marginally up, I think is a reasonable performance from that angle. Now as to the return on AUM, I think if we look at this vis-a-vis the market, I would say that we are probably still a reasonably strong performer from that angle, but why there is a dip has to do partially with the market as we have seen it, because in the equity structures, which often is the one that does contribute to a fair amount of these return on AUM, that has slowed down a bit in the last quarter because of the market conditions.
Tan Su Shan
Yeah. It is dependent on market vols and volumes, but as I said earlier on, I think we're actually moving more of that AUM to discretionary AUM so that for both run in-house and third-party.
Discretionary figure is now about $59 billion for wealth and $72 billion for wealth and retail, it's been growing quite nicely. It's very consistently every quarter this figure will grow, so that means the recurring income part will grow.
Wealth fees over AUM, it's very much dependent on the markets, but the good news is if you just keep growing your net new money, the net new money will dilute your denominator, but gradually they will convert, right, as they set up the trust and they set up their insurance and their estate planning, then they start to invest after that. It takes time for the new money to be deployed, it's not immediate, but it's just snowball.
Shee Tse Koon
The China regulations, your point is that it looks like there's been no impact on the net new money, I'll say that this is actually reasonably consistent with what we've guided in the past, because in the first place, the way by which we conduct our business has always been compliant, right? Whatever regulations that are there, we've always taken measures to be very, very compliant with how things are done, and therefore with these regulations coming, in a way it's not so direct impact.
Secondly, our franchise has always been very diversified, as we've said from many, many quarters ago, and as a result, you can see for yourself now that despite some of these new regulations, we have still been able to keep the momentum up.
Tan Su Shan
I just came back from Hong Kong, and I would tell you that our Hong Kong wealth management onshore growth has been very strong, very, very strong. The momentum continues in Hong Kong for sure, and Taiwan.
Shee Tse Koon
Yeah.
Nick Teh
Great. I think, in the interest of time, we probably have time for just two more people to ask questions, we'll go to Joanna from Jefferies and then we'll go to Nick Lord from Morgan Stanley.
Joanna, go ahead. You can unmute yourself, Joanna.
Joanna Cheah
Hi Nick, did you hear me?
Nick Teh
Yep. Oh,
Joanna Cheah
thanks for the call. Just two quick questions from me.
Just to follow up on net new money, I appreciate that you mentioned that it's quite diversified, but I actually wanted to kind of ask if you could share a little bit more specifically where the inflows are coming from from a geography perspective, any particular one to two markets kind of driving the bulk of this increase? Second question is on your GP reserves.
I noticed that has continued to kind of decline despite the kind of ongoing macro and geopolitical uncertainty. Just wondering how much scope remains for further reserve releases, and what do you think could drive credit costs higher from current levels?
Thanks.
Shee Tse Koon
I'm afraid I cannot break down for you the different geographies, because as I mentioned, our customer base comes from 100 and 110 to 120 nationalities. We run our franchise by seven regions, and then sub-teams, sub-regions, it's actually not that easy for me to just break it up for you in that sense.
Joanna Cheah
Sure. That fair to say it's quite broad-based, yeah?
There's no one to two markets that really stood out driving that $15 billion of net new money?
Shee Tse Koon
It's very, very broad-based. Very, very broad-based.
As I have said also, we do not look at it in just one quarter, right? Sometimes you'll see in one quarter, it might be a few markets, in another quarter, it's another markets.
If you look at it in totality, it has always been very, very broad-based. To the question that was asked the previous question, right, we've been consistent in what we have said, and despite what we've seen some regulations change and all that, we've been able to keep this going.
Tan Su Shan
On general provisions, two reasons. The first is we've been de-risking on the consumer loan side, our cards and unsecured loans volumes, we've been deliberately shrinking that.
That's why the GP reserves have gone down. The other is very simply, it's just repayments, right, which is not a bad thing.
We had quite a few repayments, so that's why we reduced it. Sok
Chng Sok Hui
Hui? Under our methodology, if the case is actually a very weak credit, it's not yet NPL, we actually step up our general provisions quite a bit.
I think as we communicated in the previous quarters, because of the sort of big repayments we saw, we were able to reduce the general provision allowances, that's one. Then the other one is really the de-risking of the emerging markets, the credit card and unsecured loans, we shift away to sort of the higher-quality type of financing, and so that also reduced the general provisions we needed to set aside.
It's very much a function of the business and the client behavior and the repayments that we received.
Joanna Cheah
Got it. Thank you.
Nick Teh
Thanks. Finally, Nick from Morgan Stanley.
Nick, go ahead.
Nick Lord
Can you hear me?
Nick Teh
Yep.
Nick Lord
Can you hear me?
Nick Teh
Yep?
Nick Lord
Sorry. Two questions.
Just if I can come back on this wealth issue. I guess the thing that stands out is in terms of your AUM growth is that you seem to have achieved a positive return for your clients in the quarter, which is great, but very against what everybody else has achieved.
Most people have seen negative investment returns in the quarter, I don't know if there's anything particular that you can point out that has allowed you to achieve that result? Then secondly, I just invite Su Shan to say a little bit more about what you were saying in the media call about agents.
I guess my question is, do you see a role whereby DBS will effectively develop its own agents for retail or institutional customer use and part of a product set given the risks of having other people's agents operating within your bank? I just wondered, maybe not so much from the retail side, have you had much expression of interest from your corporate clients to begin to use agents in their banking services?
Tan Su Shan
Want to answer the first?
Shee Tse Koon
I would say from, I guess, the investment calls that we have taken, we have this barbell strategy that we coined from quite a while ago and have been quite disciplined in that, right? That is something which we deploy in our own discretionary portfolio management strategy as well.
Of course with that, that is also what we use to kind of help construct portfolios advising our clients that way. If they were to follow that, by and large, when we look at our barbell DPM performance, we've been quite consistent when we compare with similar-type portfolios across the various portfolios that others have.
Like-for-like, we have always been performing within the top 4% to even in mid 9% percent top performance. If we were to kind of follow that, I would think that that would be a big contribution to how our portfolios have actually performed.
Tan Su Shan
Nick, are you looking at the wealth management AUM being up 28% whereas net new money was 15 and you're trying to triangulate the difference?
Shee Tse Koon
The mark-to-market, right?
Nick Lord
That's
Tan Su Shan
what I... FCNR was 5...
Nick Teh
That's 20.
Tan Su Shan
That's 20. Then there was some mark-to-market gains and there was some retail migration to wealth.
That would be it.
Shee Tse Koon
Yeah.
Nick Lord
Most people have seen AUM flat to
Shee Tse Koon
down. It's a mix of different reasons.
Nick Lord
Okay. You think your investment performance has been good as well.
It's just that linked to the fee side. Again,
Shee Tse Koon
if you look at our DPM, they generally outperform market benchmarks.
Nick Lord
Okay. No, that's Great.
Tan Su Shan
Okay. Nick, your question around agentic use cases and where we are.
Earlier this year, we said that we were going to roll out 12 enterprise use cases, and we call them operating model transformations. That's where we use agentic AI, we re-look our workflows, and we do massive changes to hopefully optimize and make life easier both for our customers and they get them to do more with us, but also to make life easier for our colleagues.
Are we worried? Yes, we are.
We worry about our clients divulging their passwords and what-have-you to unknown third-party agents. We worry about autonomous agents hacking banking systems.
We worry a lot about an agentic world and the risks that the financial system has to face. That one thing that causes sleepless nights, that's it.
That's why the investments that we won't compromise on is building our tech resiliency, our cyber resiliency, and our data resiliency. I think if you want to keep the trust in an agentic world, the winners and the losers will be differentiated by how strong and how ready they are in the face of these potential unknown attacks.
That's why all those investments that we've done around tech resiliency, around data resiliency, we're still doing it, but we will want to stay ahead. Then if you want to be an agentic bank, you've got to learn how to use agents in a safe way.
That includes building the harness, right? We have a lot of debates around the board as to what is the architectural coherence for an agentic bank, how do we compare with that, and what kind of sovereign models do we need to have, what kind of sovereign codes do we need to have, what kind of sovereign harness do we need to have, what kind of sovereign control planes do we need to have?
We're learning all that right now. I won't pretend to tell you that I have all the answers today.
My team and I have workshops coming out to see where we want to land. We actually did land 2 months ago, but admittedly, things changed so fast, we had to change our landing from September and maybe come up with a new landing by December on where we want to go with agents.
The early look around how we've deployed agents in operations, for example, in tech, for example, in IBG, for example, in wealth, for example, we see very good, solid early wins. I can ask Kee Juan to share with you how agents have helped him, for example, deliver more fee growth for IBG.
Han Kwee Juan
Nick, I think your question has two parts on agents. Just want to clarify if that's what you're looking for.
One is on how we're using it, and the other is are our customers asking us if we can provide agents to them as they use our system? Would that be the second one?
Nick Lord
Correct. Yeah.
Yep. Correct.
Yeah.
Han Kwee Juan
The first one, we are an extensive user of agents in our workflow. One of the things that we have done is since last year, we started to build an agentic solution for credit memo creation, which will include analysis and as well as recommendation.
That went live in April this year across 12 markets. 1,500 RMs are using it, and on a year-to-date basis, generates more than 1,800 credit memo already.
That in itself gives us the confidence of knowing how to build agents that are purpose-proved in that particular journey of credit memo. Expanding that into the external agents that we have, today our chatbot Joy in our digital banking solution under IDEAL is an agentic agent of sorts where when customers ask for inquiries, then on the back of it, we have a few agents that will pull information and then present that to the customer.
That is for information only, and it is in the background where the customers don't see it. The next thing that we are building, which is our next edition of IDEAL, we call IDEAL 9, we will be creating a hub called agents hub, and that would be based on what we see as common requests from our clients as they use our system for information and for liquidity management, for knowing how to manage the exposure.
Those we think are agents that customers are likely to call when they are using IDEAL 9, and we are doing customer immersion now to see the level of comfort that they would have in providing that to their staff as they use our systems. It's a discovery journey right now and we are thinking about that to see how customers can make their life easier when using our digital banking and then assisting them to get the outcome that they want, especially when it comes to information-gathering.
Nick Teh
Okay.
Nick Lord
Brilliant. Thank you very much.
Nick Teh
All right. Thank you, Nick.
Thank you, everyone. We're at the end of the briefing.
Thanks for joining, and we'll speak to you guys again.
Already premium?