Tania Martínez
Good morning, everyone. This is Tania Martínez, Head of Investor Relations.
Welcome to Grupo Financiero Banorte's third-quarter earnings call for 2026. Our CEO, Marcos Ramírez, will begin today's call by presenting the main results of the quarter and the 9 months of the year, highlighting the structural strength of the core business, positive trends across credit portfolio and profitability metrics, and the evolution of the main macro indicators.
Then, Rafael Arana, Chief Operating Officer, and Tomás Lozano, Chief Financial Officer, will go over the financial highlights of the group and capital allocation for the remainder of the year. Please note that today's presentation may include forward-looking statements that are subject to risks and uncertainties, which may cause actual results to differ materially.
On page 2 of our conference call deck, you will find our full disclaimer regarding forward-looking statements. Thank you.
Marcos, please go ahead.
Marcos Ramírez
Thank you, Tania. Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us today.
Let me start by saying that this has been a year with a lot of moving pieces, but our core business remains strong. We continue to see sound performance throughout the group, with healthy margins, loan growth picking up across all segments, and asset quality evolving in line with our expectations.
Overall, strong operational performance has translated into solid profitability, reinforcing our confidence in delivering on our commitments to the market as we move through the last part of the year. On the macro front, the Mexican economy has shown gradual signs of recovery despite a challenging global environment.
We have revised upwards our 2026 GDP growth forecast to 1.9%, and expect growth between 1.6% and 2% in 2027, supported by exports, improving economic and trade visibility, and gradual recovery in consumption and investment. The evolution of Plan Mexico and the roll-out of guidelines for the new infrastructure projects, particularly in the energy sector, could provide further support for economic activity, with early opportunities already beginning to emerge and potentially translating into higher investment over time.
Regarding monetary policy, given current inflation trends, we anticipate the central bank to keep the reference rate at 6.5% for the remainder of 2026. Moving into 2027, persistent inflationary pressures and the path of the US rates could lead to some tightening, potentially bringing the rate to 7% by year-end.
On the fiscal side, we expect the government to maintain its consolidation efforts, helping Mexico preserve its investment-grade credit rating. Moreover, the trade outlook between Mexico and the United States remains constructive.
Ongoing discussions regarding Section 232 tariffs on certain industries point to continued bilateral cooperation, while broader topics, such as rules of origin, labor provisions, and other technical aspects will likely to be addressed in 2027. The USMCA review remains an important focus, and continued dialogue could support deeper integration across North America value chains.
Looking further ahead, the evolution of the US-Mexico relationship, Mexico 2027 midterm elections, and the effective execution of policies aimed to of strengthening investment, productivity, and competitiveness will be key to consolidate Mexico economic recovery and sustain medium-term growth prospects. Finally, before turning to our results, I would like to briefly comment on the digital economy bill, which was recently approved by the Congress.
Our initially assessment is constructive, as the initiative has the potential to advance financial inclusion, support formalization, and accelerate the digitalization of the economy, while enhancing transparency and broadening access to financial services. Its long-term impact will depend on effective implementation and adequate infrastructure, but we believe it has the potential to generate new opportunities for the financial ecosystem.
Starting off with results, on slide number 3, our core business continues to reflect the structural strength and the resilience of our operating model. Margins remain steady, supported by a contained funding cost, accelerating lending volumes, and a favorable portfolio mix.
Although the group NIM continues to face headwinds from inflation-indexed securities in the annuities business, the strong fee generation and continued expansion of the loan book support revenue growth, driven by sustained internal demand, assertive market fit, and the continued deployment of the hyper-personalization strategy. Notably, our loan origination maintains a steady asset quality, with NPLs at 1.4%.
Cost of risk remains within the full-year guidance and continues to incorporate additional reserves from the commercial credit event recorded a year ago. On capital, organic generation remains strong, bringing our capital adequacy ratio to 22.5%, well-managing CET1 around the 13% target, while maintaining flexibility to support business expansion.
I will come back to capital allocation later in my remarks. Moving to slide number 4, net income for the quarter reached 15.7 billion pesos, up 1% sequentially and 9% year-over-year with accumulated figures, amounting to 47 billion pesos.
Results were driven by higher revenue across subsidiaries, stronger lending activity at the bank, and disciplined management of cost of funds and expenses, offsetting higher provisions associated mainly with loan origination and lower market-related income. Profitability continue to reflect business performance, with ROE for the quarter of 24.5% and accumulated ROE reaching 40- 24.7%, up 235 basis points year-over-year.
ROA stood at 2.3% as of the first 9 months, increasing 6 basis points in the same period. Analyzing results by subsidiary, on the slide number 5, bank's net income for the quarter reached 12.3 billion pesos, relatively flat sequentially, and amounted to over 36 billion pesos with accumulated figures, up 7% year-over-year.
Results reflected an improving lending mix, consistent low-cost deposit attraction, and strategic management of the funding mix. ROE remained at attractive levels, reaching 31.1% for the quarter and 31.2% with accumulated figures, up 286 basis points year-over-year.
Accumulated return on tangible equity stood at 34.6%. Insurance net income increased 2% sequentially, supported by a better performance in financial products, while premium origination normalized from the high levels of the previous quarter.
With accumulated figures, the decline merely reflects change in VAT accreditations and higher bancassurance fees, which offset increased premium volumes across the business. Annuities expanded by 72% in the quarter and 31% on accumulated basis, as business growth more than compensated for higher claims.
Pension funds continued to perform well, with a larger base of assets under management supporting revenues along with controlled expenses. Despite negative mark-to-market effects during the quarter, accumulated net income grew 11% year-over-year.
Lastly, the brokerage sector accumulated decline mainly reflected lower market valuation in the securities portfolio, despite higher transaction fees. Moving to slide number 6, Stage 1 and 2 loans reported double-digit growth of 11% versus the third quarter of 2025, in line with the upper end of our guidance.
Commercial and corporate books have gained traction, growing 13% and 11% respectively, as we start to see a gradual recovery in investment across key sectors, including infrastructure, energy, tourism, and industrial parks. In the quarter, wholesale banking balances also reflect the positive impact of the FX in our dollar-denominated book, which currently represents 14.6% of the total portfolio, recovering most of the declines related to the dollar weakening throughout the year.
Government lending increased 14% year-over-year, supported by higher activity at the federal level, despite some prepayments and amortizations from states and municipalities. Some financing opportunities around Plan Mexico are starting to emerge, potentially enabling a dynamic environment for credit origination in this segment.
Moving to slide number 7, consumer lending grew 9% year-over-year. We continue to make better use of our data and technology to deliver more relevant offers to our customers, supporting greater cross-selling and deeper penetration across our client base.
Auto loans stand out, growing 23% year-over-year, as our partnerships with leading brands, scale of our sales teams, and hyper-personalized offerings continue to support origination. Credit cards grew 10% year-over-year, supported by effective commercial campaigns, targeted promotions, and the value of our rewards and loyalty programs for our existing customers.
Payroll loans were up 11% versus the third quarter of last year, supported by a stronger value propositions that combines relevant benefits with better customer experience, giving our clients the flexibility to engage with us digitally or throughout our branch network. Finally, mortgages grew 6% in the same period, as we continue to make progress in our origination process and customer journey.
The service and process adjustments we have implemented are gradually gaining traction, supporting a better trend in the portfolio. On slide number 8, asset quality remained healthy, with NPL ratio improving sequentially to 1.4% and cost of risk for the quarter at 2.3 2.3%.
As discussed earlier, this reflects the loan growth dynamics of the period, while underlying credit trends remain consistent with our expectations. That said, we expect risk indicators to close the year within our guidance.
Slide number 9 shows continued growth in net fees, up 14% year-over-year and 15% with accumulated figures. This was supported by higher transaction volumes across our channels and products, increased lending and mutual fund activity, and a stronger transactional comprehensive platform.
Mobile financial transactions also expanded 20%, supported by a scalable infrastructure capable of processing high volumes efficiently and with a short time to the market. On the ESG front, on slide number 10, we continue our efforts for lower our Scope 1 emissions, with more than 106 branches already undergoing the sustainable certification process, thanks to their improved efficiency in energy and water consumption.
Moreover, Banorte improved its 2025 CSA Sustainability Score, reflecting our overall progress across different environmental, social, and governance performance metrics. Now let me give you an update on our progress with artificial intelligence.
As we have discussed in previous calls, we keep moving forward our visions for 1 AM per client, bringing together AI and data to better understand our customers, provide more relevant solutions, and deepen client relationships through broad selling capabilities. We are also using AI across core business segments to transform processes, with tangible results in simplifying workflows, reducing processing times, and automating repetitive tasks, allowing our teams to focus on higher-value activities.
Coding is also a good example, where these tools are already improving development speed and creating new opportunities for cost savings. Importantly, our approach combines autonomous AI capabilities with human judgment.
We see human-digital interaction as a key part of our operating model, with technology improving speed and execution, while people remain at the center of decision-pre- making. Finally, I will follow up on our capital allocation plans.
The group's organic capital generation enabled us the possibility of an extraordinary dividend during the fourth quarter. Accordingly, we are calling for a shareholders meeting tomorrow to seek approval and proceed with the distribution of 20% of the 2025 net income, equivalent to approximately 4.18 pesos per share during the fourth quarter.
With this, our total payout ratio will reach 70%. Now I will leave you with Rafa and Tomás to get into the details of the financial results of the quarter.
Rafa, please go ahead.
Rafael Arana
Thank you. Thank you, Marcos.
Thank you all for the for the heads-up that you usually send us the day before that allow us to to concentrate exactly on the on the issues that that need more more clarification and understanding. The first the first part that that we will see is that NII continued to to grow at a very very positive level as as you can see, 12% on the on the loans and and deposits.
That really shows the the ability to keep on building up the the deposit franchise. 12% has been non-interest-bearing deposit growth for the for the year, that shows really the the strength that our our commercial and corporate and and and and government banking has the ability to attract deposits at a very at a very good cost, zero cost, and a very good growth over the the the the the the the lending book.
There was also on the on the on on the on the on the quarter movements on the on the insurance side and on the on the annuity side. The annuity side had an an extraordinary month that allow us to really grow our our market share participation.
The insurance business continues to do on the on on the right track. You can see that there there are there are some numbers on the on the on the on technical on the technical research that basically on the year-to-year shows a a decrease on that part, less less claims, but the growth on the on the on the on the insurance business continue to be a very good companion to the delivery of all the the consumer building blocks on the on the on the mortgage book, on the car loans, and also on the on the credit card and on the on on the payroll.
A pretty good story for the for the for the entities concerning the the the the pension coms, the annuity, and and and and the and the and and the insurance business. You also see that the annuities is is affected by the by the inflation, but that will be corrected as you will see.
Then you'll see a a disparity on the on the technical reserves and the and the effect of the of the of basically the inflation because of the very good growth that we have during the quarter on the annuity side. The non- non-interested- non-interest income continued to be a driving force for the bank.
That really shows the the capacity for the bank to manage more and more and more activity through every single one of the channels that we use. Transactions are growing very close to the 40% per year, and and most of those transactions are accompanied by by some benefit, either on the on the on the fee side, but also accompanied the the the the entrance of that deposit side and and opening of the new accounts and activity for the overall bank.
I will move into the into the into the next year into the next graph. The bank continues to to to do well on the in in every single part of of their of their of of their revenue side, and also I will move into the cost in in a bit.
There were some concerns that the the the NIM of the bank was decreased by a bit for the for the quarter. There's a there's a clear explanation for that.
We have an extraordinary growth on the on the book, in every single part of the book. Obviously, when you when you grow you your your book, you you get basically sources from the from the deposited fund, and that gives you an an an a reduce a reduction on the margin for that quarter.
Then once the the the loan starts to to release the that margin, that margin will be balanced in the in the in the coming quarter, along with a a a large inflow that we ex- that we expect on the non-interest-bearing part. The the the the the NIM that you see at the bank level has to do a lot more with growth than anything else compared to the cost of funds on the capacity to grant and a and acquire the on the funding side.
On the on the NII, we already see the loan and deposits growing growing nicely, and the bank net fees also growing at a at a very at a very good pace. There has been also concerns that that we are overcharging on the fee side and things.
No, it it it has to do with the with the fact that the activity of the bank, as I mentioned before, has increased in a substantial way, and that allow us to really serve our client and and and companies in the in in the way that we need to serve them. Obviously, there's there's there's a charge for the service that we provide on that, but if you compare that to the market, we always below the market, as you can see on the fee structure when you look at the at the overall net income of the of the bank compared to the other peers.
We always are at the maybe at the low end of the of the fee of the fee numbers, growing nicely, but we we take very good care not to overprice on the fee side. If we move to the to the next graph basically has to do with the sensitivity management of the of the book.
Marcos already referred to that, I will not go go into that. I think we are fully prepared for either another reduction on the on the rate for the Mexican for the for the central bank or a steady space at least for seven to eight months, the the balance sheet is fully prepared fully prepared for that.
On the on the on the on the foreign side, as we don't have fixed fixed rate part of the book, it moves with the rates along along along with the rate. The sensitivity of the NII has continues to be very very low, the balance sheet is fully prepared for either a steady state on the on the rates or even of a reduction, a potential reduction in the rate.
If I move into the into the next one, the the bank continues to deliver a solid profitability for the bank, the net income 9% on the year-on-year. There was a a comment that I I I appreciate that comment because it it allows us to to explain this part.
It says is below it's it's almost expenses are growing above above the net income. Remember that expenses when when you go to the recurring part of the expense growth is below 8% on that part.
As we still have some some some expenses related to to the closing of of Bineo. TD the the the inclusion of Rappi is fully now embedded on the on that part.
Expenses will continue to be a a a single digit by the end of the year, aligned with the guidance. The fact that the net income is in in a case when you add up all the all the expense lines, but you have to take into consideration the fact of the Bineo of the of the Bineo part.
Okay? The return on equity for for the bank is at 31.1% on that part, and the ROA, 2.4% on on on on that part.
I think the bank continues to to to deliver as expected and in line with the guidance, what we provide the market with. At in the next in the next line, please.
This is the graph that allow us to to keep and and and it should give you an idea of how resilient the margin is for the for the book. You will see that the graph that is on the middle, the the the black graph with the red dotted lines, it shows exactly how we have been able to sustain the margin of the book even though the the the the steady state of the of the rates for the for the market.
The the thing that is that is relevant in in this part is that we will continue to see this evolution because we expect a very important inflow of non-interest-bearing deposits for the for the for the next 3 months, even though at this point in time net net interest-bearing deposits are growing at a pace of 12% per year. That really shows the the ability to really manage the funding the the the the the funding cost.
Big volumes with the right cost, and also on the time deposits, we are also growing and keeping the the first position in the market. The next one, please.
That shows exactly the funding cost and the and and and the split about non-interest-bearing, interest-bearing demand deposits, and also time deposits on that part that allow us to move on the. That that is a slight 45.2 that you see a small pickup on that has to be related to the fact that Marcos just mentioned.
We have an extraordinary third quarter on the loan growth, and that that really put some pressure on the on the funding cost that will be balanced out on the on the on the on the last part of the year because of the large inflow that we will get on the on the on on on the in on the on the on the funding side. Overall, funding cost in line what we expect, and it will continue to go down.
The margin on the on on the book continues to be steady. Net interest margin for the bank continues exactly as as we provide for for the guidance, I think you you will see on the on the fourth quarter also an increase on the on the margin side.
I would like to also go to to something that that somebody make a a comment also in one of of of the reports yesterday. If if if we could could go back to the to the pace of growth of the of the book.
Yeah. Let let me let me just guide you to to something that is that is is relevant concerning the the the guidance for the year.
When when you see the the the pace of growth that happened in the third quarter in the corporate or also in the government book and in the commercial book compared to what happened in 2025, you will see that in 2025 the third quarter really was like a steady third quarter and jumped into the fourth quarter. What happened this year, and we are grateful for that, because of the efforts that all the the the banks are putting in place, government, corporate, commercial, that we see what that we saw a jump a a quarter before last last year, okay?
That will allow us to keep on building the the margin, but also when you compare the third quarter to the fourth quarter on the on on this year, you will not see a strong growth like you saw yesterday. It will be a much more balanced growth.
It will be aligned on the on the low on the low part of the guidance, because the growth happened in the third quarter and not in the third in the fourth quarter. The fourth quarter will be a a base comparison that is higher that was the year before.
That has to be taken into account. It's not that the portfolio is not growing nicely, because it's growing nicely in every single part, consumer, co- corporate, commercial, but it anticipated compared to last year.
Take that into account when you see the evolution of of of the of of the loan of the loan growth on that part. That doesn't mean that we will be below the guidance, but you will not see a big pick-up like you saw yesterday the the year before on that part.
That is also quite important. Another another relevant question that you send to us yesterday is concerning the the the the the provision inside.
If we And and let me let me No, no. The one that Let me remind you this part, because if you look at the commercial line, if you look on on the on on the on the first quarter of the commercial line of '25, the commercial line was around 1.3, and it jumped to 1.5 in the second quarter of '25, okay?
Then that special case that we have been talking about that we are actively working to to to to release that that case make the commercial book to to jump to 2.8, okay? The commercial people have been working not on that case, but on the overall health of the of the of of the book that now the the the number is around 2.4.
If you normalize that to the 1.5 when we saw the pick-up, the commercial book is in better shape that it was in the in the in the third quarter of '25. Let's be very clear about that.
It's not deterioration of the book in any case. It's just that single case that we are building provisions on on that part, but that explain exactly why the the relation goes into that part.
If I now go into the consumer, if you look at the credit card on on the credit card book on on on that part and on the overall overall consumer, what you can see you can see is that some people were surprised that you the they say 826 million were the rise on the on the on on the on the provisions on the consumer. If you strip that down, only 1% of that has to do to deterioration.
Uh 86% has to do with growth, because we have been growing nicely in every single part of of of of the book, and 13% goes to the calibration that we did on the mortgage book. That explains that any concerns about deterioration of the book on that has to be stripped by growth, the recalibration of models, and really the deterioration that is only 1%, okay, on that part.
Thank you for the for the heads-up on that part, that that allows us to go deep in the explanation of of this part. Now, if I go now to the to the to the, you will see that for the quarter, based upon the the the provisions that we add and what I just mentioned about the the the growth, you see a pick-up on the cost of risk, but on a on a yearly basis, we are right on on guidance around the 1.9, okay?
I've already explained that 83% on the consumer, 86% on the consumer has to do with growth, that we have been growing nicely and getting and capturing market share in every single part of the book on the consumer side on that part. The commercial, I I think I already explained that the commercial is doing even better when you strip that that case away from from from from the book, okay?
When you look at at the at the credit risks, you have to to look at the write-off part and also the build-up of the of the provisions on on that part. We are never never at ease with with the risk, but we are actively managing the risk at a very good growth.
We are taking into consideration, and some people have concerned that our models on the credit card are let's say overweighed on the on the build-up of provisions, but remember that the market in Mexico has create what I call a a a difficult process on the for especially fro- from the FinTechs that are really building up non-current non-current clients at a very fast pace, because of the high interest rate that they charge to them. We are taking that into consideration, and our models reflect that and they are very predictive.
We are very at ease with the way we have been building of the provisions based upon the growth and the quality of the book, okay? If we if we move to the to the next one, expenses also when when they say expenses are growing above the net income, take into account the consideration that I just just just mentioned on that part.
If you take into into consideration the build-up of provisions that we have for that special case that is above 2 billion plus the the the Bineo part that is 850 mil- million, you are looking at a at a net income effect on the book very above the 3. 2 billion pesos that is already embedded on the on on the net income.
When when you release that case, and also you you finalize the the the process that we have with Bineo, you will have a a much more current way of of moving forward on the cost side. The cost will be below it will go to, as we as we promised the market, at one single-digit growth for the end of the year.
That that will also put the cost-to-income ratio at 35.5 on concerning the third quarter. A better number than the second quarter, not better than the first quarter, that you have a very large inflow on the on the on the insurance side, and then you get a a better on on on the revenue part.
I think the the cost-to-income ratio, as as we mentioned, 20- 20- 2026 is a a a leveling year. '27 will be a trend as we like to go very close to the to the 34, and then continue to go as we as we proceed also on the artificial intelligence move, okay?
If if we go to the to the next one, the capital and and and I would I like I like to to thank you, especially the bondholders and the and the equity holders of the bank, because when we jumped into the third quarter of of of 2026 and our our capital and our capital base capital was at 12.5, there were concerns that we were too too happy giving up dividends and and not taking care of the capital. No, what we are taking very good ca- care of how the bank is able to generate capital at a very fast pace, because the discipline we have on the on the risk side, that the unexpected loss is keep at a minimum level on that part, and we are not consuming capital in that part.
When you see the jump from the second quarter to the third quarter, you see a very substantial jump from 12.5 to 13.2, where we like always to be is around the 13%, maybe from 12.5, 12- 13.5, but much more closely to the 13% on the on on the core Tier 1. Now the third quarter is already at 13.2, and that capital will continue to build up into the fourth quarter.
As Marcos mentioned, that will allow us to go into an extra dividend that we have done in the past, not at the same level, but also at an important level of 4.2 pesos per share on an in additional dividend. Full We are way above the the TLAC, the TLAC part, I think the bank continues to to deploy capital at a very fast pace on that part.
We don't want to save capital for us. We would like to return to that that to the market at a safe way and in a continuous way.
I would say that that that's that basically if if we jump into into that part. I will now ask Tomás to to reinforce the the the guidance for for you.
Tomás Lozano
Thank you, Rafael. Yes, as Marcos and Rafael just discussed, we're maintaining the guidance.
If we go line by line, as Rafael just discussed about the loan growth, you are seeing these very good trends all over the portfolio, we're maintaining the 8 to 11. About the margin, as they discussed also, for the group, right now we're hovering the low end, because the inflation at the annuities, but we expect that to recover towards year-end, we're maintaining that.
The bank margin is on the high end, no, as you have seen for this year, we are at 6.8, on the high end of the guidance. The expenses, as Rafael just mentioned, we continue fully committed, and there were some questions about this.
Remember, we manage this on an annual basis, we are fully committed on delivering the expenses guidance for the year. The cost of risk, also, as has been discussed today, due to this isolated case, everything suggests that we can be on the high end of the cost of risk, but still within the guidance.
I would like to clarify what Marcos and Rafael discussed about the normalized NPL. The reported was 1.41, but if you take out this isolated case and the changes in the mortgage book, the number is 1.01.
I think this is a better description of the dynamics that we're seeing from a risk perspective. Taxes, no changes.
Net income, no changes. The other change that we really had was coming from our Chief Economist, Alex Padilla.
If you remember, at the beginning of the year, we started with a guidance of 1.4 to 1.8 in the GDP. Now we are moving that to 1.9, but other than that, we are fully committed to delivering the guidance.
With this, we conclude, and we will go back with Tania to start the Q&A. Tomás,
Rafael Arana
just one thing. Concerning the tax rate, because there was also a question about the tax rate, remember that we do that on a yearly basis.
At the first quarter we basically overload the provision on the tax rate, and then we start to level that up to finalize at the guidance by the end of the year. That was the effect that happened on this quarter.
Tomás Lozano
Yes. Thank you.
Tania Martínez
Thank you. Thank you.
We will now move to our Q&A session. As always, we kindly ask you to present only your most relevant questions, and we will be happy to follow up after the call.
Questions will be ordered on a first-come, first-served basis. Please raise your hand on the platform, and we will unmute you when your turn comes.
I'll be calling the names of the person that's next in line. If there are any technical difficulties, please let us know by using the chat.
We're now ready to take our first question from Yuri Fernandes from JPMorgan. Please, Yuri.
Yuri Fernandes
Hi, Tania. Hi, Marcos, Rafa, Tomás, everyone.
Congrats on another quarter. Rafa already mentioned a little bit about asset quality, how NPL ratios they have been behaved and some of the movements about cost of risk.
If you can help us just to understand, after this higher cost of risk from a maybe an easier comps, should we see cost of risk moving towards the guidance, Rafa, in the coming quarters? What should we think about the coverage ratio?
Because I think part of the explanation is that maybe your results they would be stronger if your coverage was flattish. Instead, we saw your coverage ratio moving up.
If you can help us just understand a little bit the dynamics of the provisions and the dynamic of the coverage ratio, I think this is an important point for investors. Thank you.
Marcos Ramírez
Thank you, Yuri. Rafa will talk about this.
Rafael Arana
Then as I mentioned, Yuri, let me start with the dynamics of what we call the NPL formation on the book and if we see deterioration of that. As I mentioned to you, deterioration if you look at the book overall, it's only 1% deterioration.
The rest has to do with a fast-paced growth that we have in every single part of the consumer book, and now also on the commercial and the government and the corporate book that is not creating any pressure on that part. The government book at the beginning demands some special provisions for a very low period of time, 3 or 4 months at the most.
We don't see that, and that is very easy to see on a line-by-line basis that we provide the market the information for them. We don't think that there's concern about the book.
We're always concerned about the book, but at this point in time, we are more concerned about that the pace of growth aligned with the quality of the book continues in the same trend that we have. We don't see really deterioration of that and we can provide that breakdown that I just gave to you that 80- 80- 80- 86% has to do with growth, 1% deterioration, and the rest, 13%, has to do with the recalibration of the models on the mortgage book on the consumer side.
On the commercial side, I already explained that the book is even performing better than before that special case that we have been building up provisions last year and this year, and we are very close to the 2 billion of provisions that have been put into that book. Believe me, we are actively seeking to become that asset current.
We don't know if that is going to happen at the end of this year, on the first quarter, or the second quarter of this year, but actively we are seeking that to be resolved. That has to do concerning about deterioration, and I think we are as I mentioned, never at ease, but comfortable with the way the growth, the risk, the expected loss, and the unexpected loss is behaving.
As I mentioned to you, the unexpected loss is very easy to measure on a very simple way: look at the pace of growth of the capital base. The other thing concerning the issue about the coverage ratio that you just mentioned, I think if Gerardo wants to jump into that, and then I close the remark about the coverage ratio.
Gerardo Salazar
Hello, Yuri. This is Gerardo Salazar, Chief Risk and Credit Officer.
I will tell you that we are considering always six factors regarding NPL normalization and cost of risk normalization. Let me begin with that.
The first factor for NPL normalization is portfolio seasoning. If I provide you some color very briefly about this normalization, and we talk about portfolio seasoning, new loan vintages mature, with delinquency gradually converging toward historical patterns.
The second factor that we're considering in this NPL normalization is stronger borrower fundamentals, and that's very important. We always consider that factor.
I don't think it needs more explanation. The third factor is improved underwriting.
What we're doing is better scoring, segmentation, affordability assessments to reduce default formation. The fourth factor we're taking into consideration in this normalization of NPLs is effective collections.
Earlier intervention improves cure rates and recoveries. The fifth one is portfolio mix, which clearly is one big explanatory variable regarding the performance of this third quarter.
The sixth one is write-offs. We agree that there could be some denominator effect that influence reported NPLs ratios, but do not necessarily represent genuine improvements in credit quality.
Those six factors are what we consider as essential looking at NPL normalization. If I look at cost of risk normalization, there's always six factors.
I will just list it very briefly. The first one is the provisioning base effects.
The second one is model recalibration, as Rafa was saying. The third one is portfolio seasoning.
In this case, stabilization of expected losses as new origination cohorts mature. The fourth one is lower default formation.
The fifth one, isolated commercial exposures, which we continue to have some very isolated cases in a very low number. The sixth one is portfolio composition.
Obviously, growth in lower-risk lending can offset higher expected losses from consumer expansion. Looking ahead, we expect NPLs and cost of risk to be influenced by portfolio seasoning, borrower repayment capacity, disciplined underwriting, and effective collections.
On the provisioning side, normalization should also reflect the absorption of model recalibrations, the absence of unusual reserve adjustments, and the evolution of isolated commercial exposures. Our focus is on stabilizing underlying default formation and expected credit losses rather than relying on portfolio growth or write-offs to improve reported ratios.
Just remember, normalization is primarily about actual borrower performance, while cost of risk normalization also reflects forward-looking expected losses, portfolio growth, model assumptions, and provisioning effects. That will be a bit of color regarding this normalization phenomena that we are experiencing.
Rafael Arana
Concerning the coverage ratio, Yuri, let me just give you a very simple explanation about that. When you see that the credit card portfolio is growing at a fast pace that we are growing, and the way we have to put provisions of day one, that is really related to that credit model that we have that demand the provisions that we have, and we have to build up the coverage ratio because of the models that we use for the credit card.
It's not that we are anticipating deterioration or anything like that. It's really related to the pace of growth of the portfolio.
We are really looking at a pace of growth for the year in credit cards very close to 900,000 credit cards. That is really a record for Banorte.
That's the number that has put us on the third place on the market. As we have always been, let's say, below our fair market share in the credit cards.
The coverage ratio has to do exactly with the way that we provide based upon us of the models that we have on the proprietary models related especially to the credit card part. That's why you see a growth in the coverage ratio, Yuri.
Yuri Fernandes
No, super clear, Gerardo, Rafa. It's not like a worsening in the environment, like more FinTechs and people getting more leveraged, it's basically growth.
You're growing more, you're providing more.
Gerardo Salazar
Exactly. That's correct.
Yuri Fernandes
Just one follow-up on the corporate case, Rafa. It's clear you're not going to reverse this.
You're working to reverse this soon. What about more provisions?
Do you anticipate more provisions for the corporate case?
Rafael Arana
Yeah. On the part on corporate cost for the year, we need around 125 more by the end of the year that needs to be put into the book.
That is already been considered as part of the guidance that we are in order to be in line what we promised the market.
Yuri Fernandes
Oh, perfect. Thanks very much, guys.
Oh, sorry.
Gerardo Salazar
Just to add on that, Yuri, at the end of this year, 72% of that credit exposure will be covered by provisions.
Yuri Fernandes
Thank you, Gerardo.
Tania Martínez
Thank you. Now we'll take our next question with Beatriz Shinye from UBS.
Please.
Beatriz Shinye
Hi, everyone. Good morning.
Thanks for the time to make questions. It's just one from our side here on profitability.
You're running at an ROE close to 25% despite a lower rate environment and relatively elevated credit costs. As we think about next year, what should we think about the ROE from here?
Is the current level sustainable? Thank you.
Marcos Ramírez
Beatriz, thank you. We think we could handle this, and as soon as we have the guide for the next year, we will release it to you.
Yes, it should be around that.
Rafael Arana
If you ask us on a long-term basis, because you have heard us saying that in the meetings that we have with you guys, 31, 32, as we have at the bank, I think on a long-term basis, that number should be much more around the 26, but has to do a lot with also the cost of capital that the country has. On the overall for the group, should be more around the 22 for the group.
On a long-term basis, okay?
Beatriz Shinye
Thank you. Super clear.
Marcos Ramírez
Thank you, Beatriz.
Tania Martínez
Thank you. Now we'll take our next question from Renato Meloni from Autonomous.
Renato.
Renato Meloni
Hi, everyone. Thanks here for taking the question.
Rafa, picking up on one of your earlier comments that you're seeing more leverage in consumers, particularly coming from the FinTechs, are you in any types of conversations with the regulator to tackle this problem and even prevent a higher overleveraged? Should we expect some measures on those to tackle those, or you think the market will self-regulate?
Thank you.
Marcos Ramírez
A tough question, Renato, but we are working as a Asociación de Bancos de México, as a ABM. We should address this to the regulator.
They know that they should be a potential problem. We don't know yet.
We are aware of that, and we will manage as soon as the pieces move, and I cannot tell you anymore because that's the truth,
Rafael Arana
no? As a response to that, Renato, if you look at the way we have been managing the entrance of this new entrants into the financial systems, I think the marketing piece that we put in place for the young people that is called Va is also as a response to that to address the fact that we needed to bring those people again into the financial system and allowing them to restart the credit cycle.
We needed to do it in a very intelligent way. We are using what we call a guarantee credit card that we basically have some funding put in place for us, and then we start freeing some line of credit into a specific credit card.
Also, if you are having a payroll, then we link your payroll to a specific credit card in order to reduce substantially the rate that we charge to those clients. To give you an idea, is less than a third of what those FinTechs are charging to those people, but at the same time, we also pay them on the guaranteed funds a reasonable return to the investor.
I think we're moving in all the pieces, because we know that we cannot send such a large amount of newcomers into the financial system to the credit bureau, and really stop them to be able to get a credit on the financial system for 5 years. As Marcos said, the regulators are already aware of that, but we are advancing on that part in order to bring those people into the financial system in a secure way, in a safe way, and I would say this is going to be a strong word.
In a decent way.
Renato Meloni
Thanks very much, guys. That's clear.
Marcos Ramírez
Thank you.
Tania Martínez
Thank you. We'll take our next question from Tito Labarta from Goldman Sachs.
Please, Tito, go ahead. Please.
Tito Labarta
Thanks, Tania. Hi, Marcos, Rafa, Tomás.
Thank you for the call and taking my questions. Yes.
A question just to follow up a little bit on the NIM. I know, Rafa, you mentioned, given the strong growth you saw that impacted NIM a little bit.
If I think overall, I think there was also some impact from inflation. Then also looking trying to compare that with the insurance, because of the annuities business, I know then in the past there's been some offsets because the technical reserves were lower, also cost of claims were lower.
How should we be thinking about the sort of the group NIM evolution also considering that insurance, the technical reserves were lower? Just to think if one is sort of compensating the other overall.
Then if I can ask just a second question on the loan growth, right? Good acceleration there.
How sustainable is this growth? Because part of it was wholesale and government.
You spoke a little bit about the consumer. How do you think about this sort of loan growth going into next year and also how that will eventually impact the NIM?
Thank you.
Marcos Ramírez
Thank you, Tito. I will start for the second one.
The loan growth for the next year in the government we will release it on next year, but should be again around double digit. We are thinking around the same as this year.
Maybe you can give us a color, Alex, how do you see the next year? Then we will go back to the first question.
Alejandro Padilla
For sure. Thank you, Marcos.
Thank you, Tito. This is Alejandro Padilla, Chief Economist.
As Marcos was mentioning in the earlier remarks, we're expecting growth next year around 2%, and I think the most important part is that the engines of growth should level in 2027. Not only the exporting sector, but we think that private consumption and investment should play a significant role as well.
Thinking about investments and Plan Mexico and all the infrastructure that Mexico requires, we're optimistic that this is getting traction. The most recent data suggests that construction and anything regarding energy and transportation that was lagging behind in previous years have been gaining momentum.
That's part of our expectations for the next year.
Marcos Ramírez
Thank you.
Gerardo Salazar
Adding on loan growth, what we are expecting regarding loan book growth, we are considering seven factors. The first one was already mentioned by Alejandro, which is stronger than expected economic growth, which is very important.
The second one is we are still banking on the premise that nearshoring and infrastructure investment are bankable up to now. The third factor, in transitory terms or for now, is the lower interest rates.
We don't know how the cycle is going to change. We know, looking forward, that the interest rates should go up eventually if expectations remain as they are now.
That factor, although is transitory, is still working and being considered. The fourth factor is consumer lending expansion.
We continue to see, as the report clearly emphasizes, a very healthy loan growth there. The fifth factor, SME banking penetration.
SME banking within Banorte has been penetrating the market more than proportionally, and that gives us a very good expectation regarding growth. The sixth one is market share gains and deeper customer relationships in several parts of the loan book.
We're seeing that, and we are eager to take advantage of those opportunities. The last and seventh factor will be greater utilization of existing credit lines.
There is more upselling, yeah, but with the customers that we really want from the risk point of view.
Marcos Ramírez
Thank you, Gerardo.
Rafael Arana
Tito, if you go to the NIM and you to ex insurance and annuities, you see a range from 6.0 to 6.3. I would say that three basis points are related to this fluctuations of the inflation rate on the annuity side.
I would say that the NIM for the group and on a steady basis should be more around the 6.3. 6.3, on top 6.4, on that compared to the 6.8 at the bank level, if you steady the inflation effect face on the annuity side.
I would say that that's what we have seen in the past.
Alejandro Padilla
Tito, on a year-on-year basis, just to give you the number in pesos, the impact is 1.2 billion of less margin related to inflation that, as you mentioned, was compensated in the technical
Gerardo Salazar
Technical reserves.
Alejandro Padilla
Yeah. Okay.
Tito Labarta
No, very thorough. That's really clear.
Thank you very much.
Marcos Ramírez
Thank you, Tito.
Alejandro Padilla
Thank you.
Tania Martínez
Now we're taking our next question with Gustavo Schroden from Citi. Please, Gustavo, go ahead.
Gustavo Schroden
Hi, guys. Good morning, and congrats on the results.
Let me explore a little bit about your cap, too. Rafa was clear in saying that Banorte does not intend to retain capital unnecessarily.
Given the current Common Equity Tier 1 position and the completion of TLAC requirements, what is the minimum Common Equity Tier 1 level that management feels comfortable with through the cycle? Understanding that target would help us to assess how much of the capital generated over next a few years would be available for distribution.
That's it. Thank you.
Marcos Ramírez
Rafael, please go ahead.
Rafael Arana
Thank you, Gustavo, for the question. The 13.5 is what we have been telling the market, that from 13 to 13.5 is in the range that we feel comfortable to be around that number.
We have also proved, and that was something that we used to have in the past years, from 12.5 to 13.5 was the range that we used to move the core Tier 1, and then the capacity to distribute funds. As 50% is what we have been basically on a steady basis released to the market.
Once we release the 50% of the net income of the past year, then we look by the third quarter what's the potential to keep building up capital based upon two things: the quality of the book and also the capacity that we have to keep building capital from our own internal operations. Also, now, concerning what Alejandro mentioned, now we see that potentially we could have a better year next year, and that will also demand way more capital in order to grow the book more.
If that's the case, I think that we will be comfortable around 13% as a minimum for the capital number, and the range to go to an extraordinary dividend will be when we reach 13.5 or above that. From 13 to 13.5 or above that, I would say that will be our guidance for the market.
Gustavo Schroden
Okay. Cool, Rafa.
If I may, just a quick one regarding the efficiency ratio, so, or the cost-to-income, we've seen a very good numbers of over the past quarters and years. Do you still see room to improve that number, we can dream with something close to 32%, 33%, or something at that level, or do you think that the bank has captured all the efficiency?
Marcos Ramírez
Gustavo, we should go there. It's a matter of time, but it should go there and even further.
That's the idea. Artificial intelligence is going to help us, and more clients, more volume.
The idea is to go there in a few years, even further.
Rafael Arana
We are not happy with the 35, eh? We are not happy at all.
We already have been at 34. We are much more comfortable below 34 that at 35.
Gustavo Schroden
Cool, guys. Thank you, and congrats again for the results.
Marcos Ramírez
Thank you.
Tania Martínez
Thank you. Now we'll take our next question from Daniel Vaz from Safra.
Please.
Daniel Vaz
Thank you, Tania. Congrats for the results.
Good morning also to Marcos, Rafa, and Tomás. Maybe a bit too soon to talk about that, but we're following the democratic sweep in yesterday US elections.
I'm trying to get a sense here is if this change in the Congress in the US improve maybe the outlook for investment in Mexico, right? We're talking about better trade policy visibility.
I don't know, we can talk back again of unlocking the nearshoring projects. Maybe if you have a sense if this would represent upside to your current loan growth expectations for next years.
If this is too soon, but which sectors tend to benefit the first? Thank you.
Marcos Ramírez
Thank you, Daniel. We saw that coming, we have an idea what's going to happen next.
Please, Alex, go ahead.
Alejandro Padilla
For sure. Thank you, Daniel, for the question.
Definitely, geopolitics is one of the key variables that we analyze when doing the forecasts. It was highly expected that the Democrats could win at least one of the two chambers.
This blue wave suggests that there should be some guard rails for some of the policies that President Trump has implemented, specifically with Mexico. What we think is that, regardless of which type of party controls the Congress, the relationship between Mexico and the US will continue to be constructive.
In that regard, I think that the bilateral talks regarding not only the USMCA extension or the annual reviews that will take place, but also what will happen with tariffs will continue to go on a very positive path. We think that Mexico has enough competitive advantages to continue integrating with the US.
We think that integrated supply chains will help Mexico to continue attracting investment, to continue to be one of the key players in trade. Just to put some numbers, as of today, Mexico represents 18% of the total imports that the US made annually.
We are the main trading partner. Mexican exports have increased so far year-to-date 30%, 3-0, 30%.
I think that's a very clear sign that the integration of North America will continue. I think that, given this change in the political landscape in the US, the trade relationship between Mexico and US will continue strengthening.
We are optimistic that nearshoring will continue to take place, and in coming years, we will continue attracting in that investment and will continue increasing exports to the US.
Marcos Ramírez
Thank you,
Daniel Vaz
Alex. Thank you for the answer.
Tania Martínez
Thank you. Now, we're taking our next question from Ricardo Buchpiguel from BTG.
Please, Ricardo.
Ricardo Buchpiguel
Hi, everyone, and thank you for the opportunity to ask questions. I have a follow-up here on one of the questions.
From the current ROE of 24%, 25% to the 22% that you mentioned as structural ROE, what are the key pieces that need to normalize in your view? Just to confirm, I assume that this doesn't factor in the efficiency improvement that you mentioned on around 32%, 33%.
Thank you.
Marcos Ramírez
Thank you, Ricardo. Rafa, please go ahead.
Rafael Arana
I think, Ricardo, the key the key is what we call principality, and has to do with the relationship that we hold with our clients that more and more the bank is really moving into a client-driven perspective on on that part. I think you see that on the on the government part, on the on the commercial and on the corporate and on that.
The consumer is also moving into that. When we when we look at the at the return on equity on on on that part, and you don't see And let me give you an example.
There are some cases when you look at a relationship with a client that maybe some of the products in an isolated way, it has a a weak ROE, but when you look at the the return on equity that the client delivers to us, then the the return on equity really jumps into the into the numbers that we would really like to like to be. If you ask me what is the driving force on that part is keep keep building the relationship with our clients that we have.
Banorte is in a very special position. Since we were a a small bank in the north, when already Banamex and BBVA were already basically the owners of the market, Banorte has been building up this customer base, but we also have share we share those clients our clients with other banks, because this this path of growth that we had.
We have a lot of of of business to be to be put into the bank from our own individual clients to keep enhancing the relationship that we have with them. Since we now price the relationship with the client on a based upon the the lifetime value that that client could deliver to us, I think the offers that those clients are receiving to become clients of Banorte are very powerful one, and we already have very good proof of that.
The return on equity has to do with principality, because principality is like economies of scale of the usage of capital and the return that you that you put that capital to use with your own individual clients on on that part. I when I talk individual clients, it's commercial, government, consumer, all all that.
I think that will be the driving force for Banorte in the in the next years.
Marcos Ramírez
Thank you, Rafael.
Ricardo Buchpiguel
Thank you very much.
Marcos Ramírez
Thank you.
Tania Martínez
Thank you. Now we'll take our next question from Natalia Corfield from JPMorgan.
Natalia Corfield
Hi, everybody. Thank you for taking my question.
I think Yuri addressed the fundamental side of the results, and my question is more related to your AT1s. I just wanted to know the plans of issuance for next year.
You have one AT1 that's callable in January, and I think we are all expecting that that's going to happen. Looking at your capitalization, I would not think that you would need to come back to the market, but you have another call in 2028, I'd like to know how you're thinking about this.
Marcos Ramírez
That's a good question, Natalia. Yes, you are right.
We cannot say anything by law, but the idea is to continue with our policies. We have some callings in the future.
The idea is to go to the markets. Banorte is very strong, we think we could make it, and we will find the window.
We were always trying to find the right window and to issue on those days, no? That's going to be the idea to be looking at the markets and looking for a good time to do it.
Natalia Corfield
We probably can expect you to be back next year.
Marcos Ramírez
Yes.
Rafael Arana
Natalia, remember that our AT1s has a specific range that we like to have. The most important thing is that the AT1s, being a local bank, are key for us to compete in what we have been really leaders in the market, in the growth on the dollar book on that part.
Based upon the demand of the dollar book, that will really condition the need to go or not to go, as Marcos mentioned, in a specific windows that we see on the market. The demand for the dollar book continues to be very strong for Banorte, and that's why we really are always looking for windows to go into the AT1s.
I will use exactly the same words that you used at the beginning of your comment about the call.
Natalia Corfield
Yeah. Perfect.
Rafa, just can you remind me what is the range of the AT1s that you think it's that you feel comfortable?
Rafael Arana
30
Natalia Corfield
to 40. 30 to 40.
Okay. All right.
Thank you very much.
Rafael Arana
Thank you, Natalia.
Tania Martínez
Now we'll take our next question from Carlos Gomez-Lopez from HSBC. Please, Carlos, go ahead.
Carlos Gomez-Lopez
Hello. Good morning, Rafael, and Marcos, Tomás.
I want to ask you about your outlook for next year, because I have to say, when I look at your numbers, when I look at how you have changed your economic assumptions, one gets the sense that you are less concerned or less conservative than you have been in the past and that you are taking a slightly more positive outlook. Is that our perception or that's indeed how you see things?
Second, going back to the AT1s. That percentage of your Tier 1, 30% to 40% that you have now, that's something that you expect to maintain for the next year, or that's something that, depending on circumstances, could go higher than that?
Thank you.
Marcos Ramírez
The first one, yes, we are more optimistic. We just changed to 1.9 the GDP for the this year, and we are moving the next year for around 2.
If you want to call it as optimistic, it's better than before. We are on that range for the next year.
Talking about the second one, the AT1s, Rafa, please go ahead.
Rafael Arana
The AT1s, I would like to stay around that numbers. If demand continues to be present in the way that they have been and there have been an extraordinary acceleration in the market, maybe for a specific period of time, we can go above the 40%.
That I don't think that will be something that we will be like a customary way of doing business on the AT1s.
Carlos Gomez-Lopez
That I understand, that is demand for dollars for you to lend, or demand for the AT1? The demand for dollars.
Not demand for your AT1s.
Rafael Arana
Demand for the dollar book that needs to be funded using the AT1s.
Carlos Gomez-Lopez
Okay. Thank you so much.
Rafael Arana
Thank you, Carlos.
Tania Martínez
Thank you, Carlos. Now we're taking our next question from Andrés Soto from Santander.
Please, Andrés.
Andrés Soto
Thank you, Tania. Thank you, everybody, for the presentation.
One of the most impressive areas of your results is your growth in deposits. They are growing even faster than your loans.
I would like to understand a little bit what is driving this. It is related to more liquidity in the market.
You're getting more principality from your customers. How are you seeing the competitive dynamics for the deposits?
What is your expectations in terms of growing deposits at the same level or even above loans going forward?
Marcos Ramírez
It's a mix of everything, Andrés. We are giving 75 trucks in the next few days.
Imagine that in the branches. Rafa, please go ahead.
No,
Rafael Arana
I think, Andrés, what you mentioned is the activity of the bank has increased, as I mentioned before, in a very important way. Every single one of the different branches of business that we have, from the government side, from the corporate, commercial, and SMEs, and also obviously the branches, are being more and more and more looking at principality of the clients.
The more we look into principality, the more we can really get on the benefit of the funding side. I would say that it has to do with principality, has to do with the activity of the branches, and see how do we really address the relationship with our clients.
Another important thing is that the way Banorte works on how to really price the relationship with the clients based upon the lifetime value that that client could deliver to us really allow us to have, on average, a better funding cost, but a better relationship with the client, because some clients get a much better benefit on the resources, other not so much, but they get another benefit on the asset side than in the funding side. On the overall, that gives that the client is happy with us, and is happy to have a full relationship with us.
I would say that that's the case. The more we get on the principality, the more the funding side will continue to grow the way it has been growing.
Marcos Ramírez
Thank you, Rafa.
Andrés Soto
Thank you, Rafa, Marcos. My last question is when you guys think about 2027, what is your main concern, if anything?
It is a persistent delay in investment recovery in Mexico, continued asset quality deterioration at the system level, competition both from traditional bank and FinTechs, or any other factor that I'm not mentioning here?
Marcos Ramírez
I would say all of the above, but I would say the environment with the policies of the government and all that,
Andrés Soto
no? More related to a persistent delay in investment recovery.
Marcos Ramírez
Yes.
Andrés Soto
That's very clear. Thank you, Marcos, and congratulations, guys, on the results.
Tania Martínez
Thank you, Andrés. With this, we conclude our presentation.
Thank you, everyone, for your interest in Banorte.
Already premium?