Modiv Industrial, Inc.

Modiv Industrial, Inc.

25.18
USD
+0.03
(+0.10%)
0.98EPS
42.65P/E
186.87MMarket Cap

Q4 FY2025 · Earnings Call TranscriptMarch 25, 2026

Operator

Please note this event is being recorded. I would now like to turn the conference over to Sarah Grisham, Chief Accounting Officer.

Please go ahead.

Sarah Grisham

Thank you, Operator, and thank you, everyone, for joining us for Modiv Industrial's fourth quarter and full year 2025 earnings call. We issued our earnings release after market close today, and it's available on our website at modiv.com.

I'm here today with Aaron Halfacre, Chief Executive Officer; Ray Pacini, Chief Financial Officer; and John Raney, Chief Operating Officer and General Counsel. Before we begin, I would like to remind you that today's comments will include forward-looking statements under the federal securities laws.

Forward-looking statements are identified by words such as will, be, intend, believe, expect, anticipate, or other comparable words or phrases. Statements that are not historical facts, such as statements about our expected acquisitions and dispositions and business plans, are also forward-looking statements.

Our actual financial condition and results of operations may vary materially from those contemplated by such forward-looking statements. Discussion of the factors that could cause our results to differ materially from these forward-looking statements are contained in our SEC filings, including our reports on Form 10-K and 10-Q.

With that, I would like to turn the call over to Aaron. Aaron, please go ahead.

Aaron Halfacre

Thanks, Sarah. Hello, everyone.

Hope you're doing well. Crazy times, I know I'm looking forward to this call, and I'm sure you are too.

Let me start off by saying, Sarah just read the standard preamble that everyone has, and it talks about forward-looking statements. I spend the vast majority of my time thinking about forward things.

The historical things and the things that are measured, the accounting, are really important. This is a poignant time because this is going to be Ray's last earnings call, even though Ray is going to be with us for the remainder of the year.

This is his last official earnings call, and John is going to be taking over the helm. I just really want to speak and thank our team.

Sarah, John, Winnie, Lamont, Jason, all the accounting team in particular, which is candidly more than half of our company, does such a good job. They make my job easier so I can spend all this time talking about the forward-thinking things and dealing with these things that don't always have measurable outcomes.

That messy part of it that I do is that much easier because of how good they are. I appreciate that they're all here.

Just wanted to welcome Sarah to the call, even though she's always been there in the background. She's going to be part of the call now along with John going forward, and, of course, Ray.

With that, let me sort of shift in gears. I'm sure we're going to have a whole host of interesting questions.

I have no idea if I can answer your interesting questions, but I will do my best. First, let's let Ray have the stage and do his thing.

Ray?

Ray Pacini

Thank you, Aaron. I'll begin with an overview of our fourth quarter operating results.

Rental income for the fourth quarter was $11 million compared with $11.7 million in the prior year period. The decrease in rental income reflects the expiration of our lease with Costco on our office property in Issaquah, Washington, which was sold to KB Home on December 15th, 2025, and expiration of our lease with Solar Turbines on an office property in San Diego, California, which we plan to market for sale upon receiving approval from the city of San Diego for a lot split.

Fourth quarter adjusted funds from operations, or AFFO, was $4 million compared to $4.1 million in the year-ago quarter. The $30,000 decrease in AFFO reflects a $554,000 decrease in cash rents, which was partially offset by a $299,000 decrease in cash interest expense, a $138,000 decrease in preferred stock dividends, a $40,000 decrease in property expenses, and a $15,000 decrease in G&A.

AFFO per share decreased from 37 cents per share in the prior year period to 32 cents per share for the fourth quarter of 2025. The decrease in AFFO per share was primarily due to a 1.7 million share increase in diluted shares outstanding, which reflects previously disclosed issuance of operating partnership units during the first quarter of 2025, along with the issuance of common shares in our ATM and distribution reinvestment plan.

Interest expense for the quarter was $1.1 million higher than the comparable period of 2024, primarily due to amortization of off-market interest rate swaps. With respect to our balance sheet and liquidity, as of December 31, 2025, total cash and cash equivalents were $14.4 million, and we have $30 million available to draw on our revolver.

Our $262.1 million of consolidated debt outstanding consists of a $12.1 million mortgage on one property, excluding a $12.1 million mortgage on the Santa Clara property that was owned by tenants in common and therefore not consolidated as of December 31, 2025, and $250 million of outstanding borrowings on our $280 million credit facility. Following the January 2026 extension of our credit facility, we do not have any outstanding debt maturities until July 2028.

Based on interest rate swap agreements we entered into in January 2026, 100% of our indebtedness as of December 31, 2025, held a fixed interest rate, with a weighted average interest rate of 4.15% based on our leverage ratio of 45.1% at quarter-end and the January amendment to our credit facility. I'll now turn the call back over to Aaron.

Aaron Halfacre

Thanks, Ray. Operator, let's just go to questions.

This will just be easier.

Operator

Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, we will now begin the question-and-answer session.

Should you have a question, please press star followed by the 1 on your telephone keypad. You will hear a prompt that your hand has been raised.

Should you wish to cancel your request, please press star followed by the 2. If you are using a speakerphone, please lift the handset before pressing any keys.

One moment, please, for your first question. Your first question comes from the line of Gaurav Mehta from Alliance Global Partners.

Please go ahead.

Gaurav Mehta

Thank you. I wanted to ask you, I think in the press release you talk about receiving multiple offers and spending some time on one of those, and, in the end, not pursuing it.

Just wanted to get some more color on what those reasons were for not pursuing the offer.

Aaron Halfacre

I figured you'd ask that. I don't really have an answer that I can give you other than to say that we, at that moment, didn't see a secure path forward, we stepped back from discussions.

I think, fundamentally, there was the vast majority of the stuff there was good. It's just that our job is to protect our investors and to make sure that we have put forward the requests that we need to make sure that our investors are going to get what they're going to get.

It was just a process. I think that it was a generally positive exchange.

Sometimes these things happen where it's not quite flowing. That's about all I could say.

It doesn't give you much. As it relates to that, we just, in that particular moment, didn't see a secure path forward, and so we stepped back from discussions.

Gaurav Mehta

All right, thanks for that color. Maybe on 2026, just wondering, as far as asset recycling, are you guys expecting to sell any assets this year, and then maybe some comments on the acquisition environment that you guys are seeing?

Aaron Halfacre

On a go-forward basis, recycling will will, as I've mentioned in January, will start to pick up in earnest. I I'd say, the stuff that's happened in the last two or three weeks might is is going to, cause it's it's hard, right?

It's hard for pipelines, it's hard for dispositions, because you've you've got rates just gyrating all over. That that just really stings confidence for for buyers and sellers in general.

I think, appetite is always there, but it's hard. It's just hard.

You If you're a buyer, you're pricing in a huge margin of safety because, you could be wrong. If you're a seller, you don't want to sell and and and, do do a deal that you would regret literally 30 days later, right?

That the landscape has changed a lot. I think the near term is it's a little bit harder, a little bit cloudier, but it's not any candidly, it's not any different than than before.

Let let's assume that the trend long term, barring $200 barrels of oil, is that we will eventually find REITs returning to favor, right? I think all of us here on this call probably presume this at some point.

It's certainly been long in the tooth, and we would have liked seen it sooner, but this is a narrative we have. We will continue on our recycling.

I think the way we're thinking about the recycling in this is a couple of different phases. The first phase is really looking at like we have some non-core assets, particularly office.

Those are going to get we're going to get rid of those, right? There's only two office properties we have.

One is Solar, which, as went the not Solar, it's the property in San Diego that was formerly leased to Solar Turbines. They left the end of September.

That's why we had a little bit of fall-off, which is inevitable in in in, rents in the fourth quarter. That property is a great property to sell to an owner-user.

We've actually had quite a bit of interest for it. The interest has been above the appraised value of the property.

The reason why we haven't sold it yet, or the flip side, the reason why we haven't leased it, is that it was or or it is on the same technical parcel as our WSP property. They're right next to each other.

This was a property that was acquired by the prior legacy team. We've had it We have been working through the bureaucratic process that is not uncommon in any county or city since 2021.

Five years now trying to get that parcel split in in so that it has its own parcel and we can sell it separately. We are we are so close to that.

We are at the final, very detailed scrutiny like filing refiling parcel maps, and I mean the the little things like ADA slopes on things. All that stuff is done.

We're super close to that. When once we are have that in hand, then we will take that property to market.

The reason why we haven't leased it is because, look, we I think the owner the right user of that is an owner-user or some sort of, some sort of tenant who might want a 5-year lease or might want a gross lease or We want long-term industrial manufacturing tenants. On that lease basis, you can't that's not going to fit that box.

That box has a better use. We will sell that one.

That's an office property technically. It's really a flex space.

If you look at it now from what it was before, it's like completely a open, clean shell. It's ready to go, right?

That'll get sold. My guess right now, if you were to put a gun to my head, that's like, call it, $7 $7 or $7 million, $8 million.

Right? It's not a huge number.

The other off office property is OES. OES has this purchase option.

We've talking to them. They like it's a blue I mean that's an investment-grade tenant, but it's a government, right?

That's got We think that's a super sticky asset, but it's not a net-leased manufacturing asset, we're going to and it is office. It's a balancing act.

We've waited. We don't, if we'd sold it 2 years ago, it probably sold at like a 10-cap, and who wants to do that when you've got, really good rent that's coming in?

You have to be patient. At some point, you're like, okay, you got to shit or get off the pot.

We'll clean that one up, and, that's that that'll happen ideally by the end of the year. I don't we're going to be thoughtful about the timing.

We're not going to force it, but it's moving forward to no longer delayed. That's the obvious part.

People ask about the Kia dealership. It's a non-core asset.

That one is a the the conundrum with that one, that's a layup to recycle, right? We've seen interest in that one, not offers, but interest that at or below the cap rate that it's appraised at.

It's a very attractive asset, but it's a big one. It's $70 million, call it, property.

That was a 1031, excuse me, a UPREIT transaction from from about 5 years ago. We have a really low tax basis on that one, it's supersensitive.

If you're going to sell it, you have to make sure you already know what to buy. To buy, I don't want to buy a $70 million industrial manufacturing facility.

I would be better served buying, sort of three $23 million industrial manufacturing facilities and rolling it into it, right? That will be an accretive transaction because, our we'll talk about forward pipeline here in a bit.

That cap rate that that's selling at, our we would sell at, the the Kia, is at least at least, if not more, 100 basis points tighter than what we can redeploy it in. That would be generative.

We have to line that up, because you can't just take it to market. You would get bids undoubtedly.

A lot of those bids would be fast-closing bids, and then you would be left with a short window to 1031 designate. We're we'll be patient on that one in terms of non-core.

That'll happen when we find the right target to roll it into. Setting that non-core aside, obviously we move the office.

Then from there, we have a lot of short WALT. Our short WALT philosophy is this: We will do our darnedest to see if they will extend.

We will have conversations with them. Are we are starting to do those conversations.

If they're willing to extend, and that just extends like, 2 years, I think these really give us something that makes us decide we might want to keep it for longer term, or if they don't, realizing that, let's just clean up the WALT. Even though they're great tenants, I think our goal is a vision is, let's get to a a rock-solid portfolio long term.

We understand that as leases get shorter, and you see this in sort of O and W. P.

Carey, that you get down to the option periods, and CFOs and things like that typically just they just exercise 5-year renewals, 5-year renewals, they exercise their option periods. That's normal.

We have a period of time right now that we can positively take positive arb by selling certain assets, even if they're shorter WALT, and creating, more AFFO by reallocating them into longer WALT and having a a more solid portfolio. We'll spend time this year looking at.

Northrop was one of those properties. We got an unsolicited offer that came in.

It was worth our time, was worth our energy. We gave them We were patient with it.

We were not in a rush for them to do their due diligence. We were not in a rush for them to close because we we didn't need to roll it into a a replacement property ideally.

There's other uses for it, too, and we'll get into that, but we can use that money fungibly. That was one that is an example.

That's a property that, look, it's a short WALT, we got an offer that was compelling, and we took it. That that's on that.

We will see more of that activity. Separate from that phase is, we have a few industrial credits that I probably like to recycle through.

There's nothing wrong with them, they're perfectly fine, but just smaller, they're less institutional. They would I think recycling those at the right point, and that might be this year, might be early next, will allow us to just clean ourselves up that much more.

When I say clean up, it doesn't mean we're dirty. It just means I want to polish it as best we can, because I think the process that we've been through with these these offers and the interest and it it's helped us say, "Hey, like like if we do these things and extract the value for our shareholders, then it we're going to be in a really solid position."

Outside of that, we have a few, and I mentioned this before in January, sort of some opportunistic assets that are great assets. They may not be manufacturing assets.

They're certainly lower cap rate assets that, at the right time, if we got ready or we had clearly identified things to buy, we would roll those as well, right? You will see more activity over the course of this year, barring something bigger and strategic happening.

You'll see more activity in the course of this year and next. We're not Those were Those weren't just words.

Those were actions that we're going to take. I think the the the interesting thing about all this is they're all, as I mentioned before, they're all tax sensitive in terms of we have low basis.

If we don't redeploy them in 1031, investors are going to have, taxable events. We just, that's not how you're supposed to manage a REIT, we're trying to be thoughtful about that.

The selling of the assets is actually pretty easy. You could happen pretty quickly, and a lot of brokers ready to go.

If you put a property on there, you probably are sold in 60 days if you really wanted to, but comfortably 90. The problem is finding replacement properties that line up.

I'd say, over the course of our journey, I've gotten I've gotten and the team has gotten a lot more selective in terms of you want really good manufacturing products. The products that they're manufacturing's got to be really good.

We've We've gotten that right. You want to make sure that the the lease structure is really good.

You want to make sure that the financials of that tenant are really good. You would like ideally like that tenant to only have one source of manufacturing, which is your thing, or you have control of all their manufacturing, so that you can't get rejection in a bankruptcy proceeding, God willing if it ever happens, but you're addressing that through credit.

You'd also really like to have good location as best as you can, and and then on top of that, a good cap rate. Those are a lot of Those are a lot of fine wish lists.

You can't be, you can't be the Princess and the Pea about it. You have to really be compromise on marginal areas if you have to, but we don't have to right now, and we've been patient.

The pipeline has been episodic. It's been erratic.

We started to see pipeline come out in January, and some of it's just like We're still Some Some Some times we're still still waiting for the OMs, right? They're like.

It's like the OMs haven't come out. Why?

Because the person on the other end is concerned about selling, right? We might want to be bidding with a margin of safety.

They're They're wanting to They're wanting to sell with security that they know they're going to get it. This is a a stable ground, and that they go and go out in the market, they're going to execute on what they think they are, and it's not going to just change on them.

It's a little bit of weird time in that regard. We're we're looking at our box, buy box, making sure we're looking We're looking at a lot of things.

I'd say price talk overall is interesting. If you go look at the $22.19 NAV per share we have, which, look, we everyone has an NAV, right?

Some people use a Street analyst NAV. Most REITs have an internal NAV of some sort.

We have the Our internal NAV happens to be done by a blue chip appraisal firm, Cushman & Wakefield, and they've been doing it for, I don't know, 6 years. There's consistent history.

You go piece it together. You're like, eh, appraisals are full of shit, right?

They don't They're not real. They they actually are pretty indicative.

I would tell you that we have three I I can think of three properties in our portfolio in the last 6 months where we have received unsolicited offers that are at or below the cap rate that is implied in our appraisals. We've all I think we all understand, particularly now in this environment, that there's a fairly large disconnect between private real estate and public real estate, and public real estate's just taking it on the chin repeatedly.

We're we understand that. That 22.19 NAV, I think round numbers is a six it's an implied 6.8 cap rate.

First you're like, well, you're not trading anywhere near that, and we're not. Price talk we've seen, and price talk is maybe like an appraisal.

It's it is indicative of something. Doesn't mean it's transactional, but it's in the range of possible.

There's a there's a $200 million portfolio going out there today. It has a tenancy that's very similar to our largest tenancy in terms of the sector.

It's got they're talking 6.75 on that one. We saw another property where someone was talking 6.75.

Now, that's broker talk. They're leading a little bit.

Do I think it's going to trade there? Probably it's going to trade wider than that.

Might be 7, might be 7 and a quarter, but clearly, you're seeing stuff between 6.75 and 7 and a half all, right now. You just got to find the right thing.

Sometimes you'll find something that might, if something is 7 and a half and it's just it's just dog doodoo, you don't want to pay 7 and a half. If something is great and it's a 7, then you can do it.

Sometimes there's dog doodoo that's 6 and 75, too. It's just, everyone's trying to do their own thing.

I would say that the pipeline right now, and and it's got a little bit of a strobe light effect when you see it. Sometimes it's there, sometimes it's not when the light comes back on, is is tighter than it was a year ago.

It does feel tighter to me. Whereas a year ago, I was probably saying 7 and a half to 7 and 3 quarters.

It's now the talk has gotten tighter. I think that might be a little bit of the optimism that we saw 3 or 4 weeks ago.

Now I'm not really hearing calls for the last 2 weeks, but I think everyone's kind of holding their breath, right? The first weekend with the conflict, we were like, oh, is this going to be like the last time where we just bombed them and then we went back to business?

Then no, it's now extended. Then, we've gotten all as a collective gotten ADHD where we're like, oh no, it's been an 18-day war.

Historically, we've had wars that lasted for years. I don't know if you can hold your breath on this one.

It might be over soon. It might not be.

It's certainly volatile, and you certainly got to stick to your knitting. It's a long-winded to say way of saying that we see opportunity.

We're looking at it. We're just being extremely thoughtful.

It takes an inordinate amount of patience, which is very hard to do. It it's very hard to do.

It's not fun. It's not sexy.

It, it's it's I wish I was a an AI company. That would be fun.

We're not. Sorry for the long-winded answer.

Hope that helps.

Gaurav Mehta

No, thanks for those details. I appreciate it.

That's all I had.

Operator

Thank you. Your next question comes from the line of Jay Kornreich from Cantor Fitzgerald.

Please go ahead.

Jay Kornreich

Hey, thanks. In line with a lot of comments there, obviously a lot of questions on the macro perspective at the moment.

I guess if we could just wrap up all those comments you just made about the transaction front and how you're thinking about that going forward, do you still feel on track to get the portfolio to the 100% pure-play manufacturing industrial over the next 24 months, or does maybe the timeline shift just with everything that's going on at the moment?

Aaron Halfacre

I do, because I always like to underpromise and overdeliver, whatever the phrase is. That 24 months, look, I think if things are rosy and the market starts hit and it's dry, that's a 12-month process, right?

It can be a lot tighter. Again, the bottleneck is having the right assets to acquire, and the right assets to acquire will become much more evident when the market gets a little bit more stable.

Theoretically, just putting out our portfolio, if I identify the right portfolio of assets as an example and I had the right timing to buy them, that I could almost, in effect, do it in one fell swoop, right? Just mathematically if you think about it.

It's not going to happen likely because it's hard to find these things, but doesn't mean it can't happen, and it doesn't mean we're not looking. If you found a $100 million portfolio of assets that you liked, that you could line up to purchase, that met your box, and then you could take your assets out to market, they would all be reverse 1031 or forward 1031 designated exchange, and you're done in one fell swoop.

It's the pipeline that matters. Yes, I do think 24 months is very realistic and doable.

Jay Kornreich

Appreciate that. Then just one follow-up.

I recognize that there's little commentary you can provide on the potential acquisition offers that you received, but can you maybe just from a different angle talk about what's perhaps brought you more on the radar of others more recently as an acquisition target, maybe relative to a year ago? Is it the state of interest rates?

Is it the progress you've done on the asset recycling efforts? Is it something else?

Just what do you think has brought you more into the limelight of others looking for a portfolio like yours, and how do you expect additional potential inbounds moving forward?

Aaron Halfacre

That's a good question. I think, look, the discount for public REITs to private real estate has been persistent.

We've started to see REITs get picked off. In some ways, you could argue why hasn't there been more M&A volume?

There's still been a decent amount of M&A activity. All right, in our space, you obviously had the real germane thing, you had sort of Fundamental, which was a not public, but they got taken out by Starwood.

You had Plymouth taken out. You had Peakstone taken out.

Broader than that, you had Alexander & Baldwin, you just had the NSA deal, we've had a lot of different names get consumed. I think a lot of them were smaller-cap names, which means that there's a greater buyer pool of people who can afford to take those out.

I think there's been a trend where, for a while now, if you had raised a value-added opportunistic fund in '23, you've got a 3-year investment window, maybe. Or you raised it in '24, you've got a 3-year deployment window that you got to get deployed.

At some point, people were starting to deploy, and they're waiting, and Well, we started seeing signs as early as the third quarter of last year where activity started to pick up, and we've seen a fair number of those things. Once that starts happening, people start looking, right?

Once you decide you're a seller, then you're potentially a seller, so that attracts buyers. If you're decidedly a buyer, you start to look for things to buy, right?

I think that's been the first thing. I think the near-term volatility in rates and global economic pictures is frustrating that on the margin.

Again, I don't think that's changing directionally where things are at, is that people see attractive long-term positive leverage opportunities in public real estate, either public-to-public, or like we saw with Public Storage, or it's a public-to-private, right? We've seen this at different times.

Look, there are probably too many REITs out there. There are too many undercapitalized REITs out there.

We are in one of those buckets, we understand. People say, "Why did you ever go public?"

At the time, we were a non-traded REIT, and we knew that we didn't provide immediate liquidity. We would be gating, and no one wants to gate.

Ask BREIT, ask Starwood REIT that thing. They're much bigger so they can afford to do it, but no one wants to be that.

We provided liquidity for that generation of investors, and we've recycled, and we've just been in a rough time. We've created a valuable portfolio.

I can't, off the top of my head, I would think our share price is a ridiculously wide cap rate to the assets. That's what's attracting people.

They're like, "Hey, you've got 14 years, you've got 2 and a half percent in place, you've got manufacturing tenants that don't have obsolete." Arguably that the real estate is already obsolete in the sense that it's not whiz-bang, it's been doing this stuff for 40 or 50 years, it's really good durable real estate, and it's still here, right?

If you bought a 2018 vintage data center, it's already obsolete. You already have to replace all the guts on it other than the shell of the box.

If you bought a 1999 warehouse, it's obsolete, right? Our stuff arguably is not that sexy, it's older real estate, but it doesn't have any more obsolescence value.

You're buying it for core income-producing value. With the EBITDA to rent coverage and the fixed-charge coverage ratio of our tenancy, it's a strong portfolio.

If you look long term and think, hey, long term, not right now though, because if you look at in the futures market the ZB or the UB in the long bond, they've sold off, right? Which is counterintuitive that in the short term with war, they typically rally, but they sold off, which have made rates go up.

If you think longer term, that we'll have a yield curve that suggests that long-duration assets with low leakage in terms of NOI, and particularly the advent that we can start putting private capital into retire 401(k)s and things like that, there's a natural demand for this nice pool of portfolio. We are synergistic, right?

I'll give you the color, is that the people looking at us were not looking for the team. They're looking at the assets.

I wish they were looking for the team. It'd be fun to do that, but they're looking at the assets.

It's pretty simple. You can strip out the G&A, and it becomes accretive.

We're not opposed to selling. We're just wanting to make sure it's the right value for our investors, because we're not desperate.

We're not going to just give it away. That might be a great payday for me, because all I do is I have equity like everyone else.

We're going to do the right thing, and the right thing will come about. In the meantime, we're going to pay that 10 cents a share per month and get it done.

I think the interest is because there's really good value coupled with there's people who have money, and they're starting to decide they want to make allocations. I think the last element is, look, there are arguably four small-cap industrial REITs that I can think of, and maybe you include ILPT in there, maybe that's five.

Of those five, ILPT and Gladstone are externally managed, good luck with that, right, getting a hold of those. The other three were Plymouth, Peakstone, and us.

Clearly, we're the smallest. I think that's part of it, too.

There's just, if you want to pick up this sector, you like this space, there's not a whole lot you can do, right? That's where we're at.

Jay Kornreich

Got it. All helpful commentary and perspective, thanks, and I'll stop it there.

Aaron Halfacre

Thanks.

Operator

Thank you. Once again, that is star and 1 to ask a question.

Your next question comes from the line of John Massocca from B. Riley Securities.

Please go ahead.

John Massocca

Good afternoon.

Aaron Halfacre

Hey.

John Massocca

I know you've kind of talked a lot about the inbound interest after the January 20 update, but I guess given that you've seen that, does that maybe spark an interest in running a kind of strategic alternatives process earlier than that, I guess maybe that kind of 24-month timeline that was kind of talked about in that update? Just kind of curious how that changes your mindset, if at all.

Aaron Halfacre

I think the interest suggests to me that people know there's value here, and that they know that we can clean up the portfolio. Look, again, the portfolio's not dirty, but if it's more polished, it's going to be more valuable.

They see a window of opportunity. If they can take it out cheaper than what it will be in the future, that's their job.

Their job is to try to take it, keep the upside for themselves, and give you a few shekels. I think what this suggests to me is that, barring someone closing that value gap, and closing that value gap does not mean $22.

Let's just all be clear. No one's going to do that.

No investor in their right mind, or buyer in their right mind, is going to do that. There's no upside, right?

They want that, they just buy a bond. Right?

They need upside, but our investors need upside. It's a dance of where that is.

What it suggests to us is that if we didn't have, if I'm going to go buy a used car, and that car has got a little bit of rim rash in the back wheel or there's a little bit of scratch on it, I'm going to use that to get lower price. What we have the ability to do is polish that portfolio up.

That it's even more valuable. If you flash forward in this environment, let's think about where we're at right now.

We're in a super crazy rate environment, right, where people are yelling stagflation, and bonds are doing this, it's crazy. You're like, what do you expect if you went and ran a process now or in 6 months?

Right? If you did it where you flash forward, you clean up your portfolio, you're humming, you're good, the rate environment is stable, maybe it's lower, but it's certainly stable, you've clearly gotten what it is, you know you can extract more value, and you've done that, and let's say that is in 24 months.

Let's just put that hypothetical situation there. In that 24 months, our investors, assuming no change in our dividend, no increase or decrease in our dividend, which look, I'm not decreasing the dividend, but let's assume no increase either, that's $2.40 of income in the next 2 years and a higher value of your portfolio to execute.

You would try to buff out the scratches, you would try to get rid of the rim rash, you would get yourself in an environment where your type of car that is for sale is in demand. Doing so prematurely would suggest one of two things in my mind.

It would suggest doing so prematurely is running a strat alts process, to be clear. It would suggest either, one, your leadership doesn't want to do it or can't stomach it, and look, it's not fun sometimes, but we don't have weak stomachs here.

Or two, you think you can't do any better. Otherwise, why would you do that?

Why would you shortchange the investor? You just wouldn't.

If an opportunity comes along that closes that value gap and you just say, "Well, okay, this is pretty good. This is going to give them a chance to redeploy their capital, or this is going to be another public currency where they can continue to get dividends and participate in the REIT upside," there's a lot of different ways to look at this.

If someone could do that better, we're all ears. It doesn't mean just because you've gotten interest that you should now sell, right?

Look, if you did go under an offer, unless it was an offer where you felt secure and there was no go-shop associated with it, you are effectively having a process there. I just think really thinking about it philosophically, you have to think about what does a strat alts process suggest?

I think there's been a lot of REITs out there that are undergoing strat alts processes, even if they're quiet or they're done some publicly. I don't know this is the right time to do that.

Why are you trying to sell right now if you have to? If someone wants you, that's one thing.

Why would you try to sell?

John Massocca

That makes sense. Getting on a more detail level, and apologies if I missed this in the prepared material, what were the potential terms of the Melbourne, Florida office sale, or is that kind of TBD?

Aaron Halfacre

The terms are well known to us. As a respect to that buying party, and respect to us, I like to keep those silent until after the fact.

Suffice it to say is we have slightly over $400,000 of earnest money that's gone hard. This has been a process.

This was not a fast deal. It was an organized, methodical one.

Once it closes, I'll inform you of what it was. I'll tell you right now, just to be clear, what we don't have right now, and we're working on that, we don't have a replacement property identified yet.

We don't need to worry about this one, so that's okay, in terms of the tax sensitivity. Why is that?

Because we're selling Cholera, and let's just all be honest, we took a loss on Cholera, and so that creates a tax loss that shelters the gain on this one. We have a little bit of time to be thoughtful about the redeployment of that.

It's scheduled to close in the second quarter. Once it closes, which my guess is, we will absolutely tell you what happened on it once it closes.

John Massocca

Okay. Then with the former Cholera property in mind, can you remind us what the kind of I guess cost of carry was for that in 4Q or kind of the OpEx cost associated with that asset in 4Q that's going to go away now that you sold it in January?

Roughly?

Aaron Halfacre

Ray, do you know roughly off the top of your head? It wasn't terrible, to be honest with you, but...

Ray Pacini

I think it was running about 20, 30 grand a month.

John Massocca

Okay. That's it for me.

Ray, appreciate all the help over the years. I'll miss you on these calls.

Thanks.

Operator

Thank you. There are no further question at this time.

Please proceed. All right,

Aaron Halfacre

everyone, thank you so much. I know we came out a little bit later.

That was because of the aforementioned offers. Don't like to come out as late, but we are a pebble in causing a ripple in the ocean that is raging right now.

Appreciate all that did join, wishing you the best of luck for your families and your portfolios, and talk to you again next quarter. Thanks so much.

Operator

This concludes today's call. Thank you for participating.

You may all disconnect.